<!DOCTYPE html> <html itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/NewsArticle" lang="en" class="blog layout_article rendering-context-www outputtype_default-article"> <head> <script>window.pbDeferredScripts=window.pbDeferredScripts||new Array;</script> <script id="_$cookiemonster">(function(document,undefined){var wl={};wl.reg=[];wl.map=[];function CM(wlmap,wlreg){this.wl={map:wl.map.concat(wlmap||[]),reg:wl.reg.concat(wlreg||[])}}CM.prototype.ommNom=function(){return this.nom(true,undefined)};CM.prototype.allows=function(cookieKey){var yum=this.nom(false,[cookieKey]).indexOf(cookieKey)>-1;return!yum};CM.prototype.nom=function(deleteCookies,cookiesList){var unset=[];var domainkey=document.location.hostname.split("").reverse().join("").slice(0,18),dcookies=cookiesList||document.cookie.split(";"),
dcookie,save,reg;for(var i=0;i<dcookies.length,dcookie=dcookies[i];i++){save=dcookie.trim().split("\x3d")[0].toLowerCase();if(this.wl.map.indexOf(save)>-1);else unset.push(save)}for(var o=0;o<this.wl.reg.length,reg=this.wl.reg[o];o++){reg.lastIndex=0;for(var i=0;i<dcookies.length,dcookie=dcookies[i];i++){save=dcookie.trim().split("\x3d")[0].toLowerCase();if(reg.test(save)){if(unset.indexOf(save)>-1)unset.splice(unset.indexOf(save),1)}else if(unset.indexOf(save)<0&&this.wl.map.indexOf(save)<0)unset.push(save)}}if(deleteCookies)if(domainkey==
"moc.tsopnotgnihsaw"&&(this.wl.reg.length||this.wl.map.length))setTimeout(function(ctx){return function(){for(var i=0;i<unset.length;i++){document.cookie=unset[i]+"\x3d; expires\x3dThu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:01 GMT; path\x3d/; domain\x3dwww.washingtonpost.com";document.cookie=unset[i]+"\x3d; expires\x3dThu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:01 GMT; path\x3d/; domain\x3d.washingtonpost.com";document.cookie=unset[i]+"\x3d; expires\x3dThu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:01 GMT; path\x3d/; domain\x3d"}}}(this),0);else console.error("[cookie-monster] Cowardly refusing to delete cookies on "+
document.location.hostname,unset);return unset};document.__CookieMonster__=CM;return CM})(document);</script> <script>(function(document,cwlobj,map,reg,value){cwlobj={"cookies":["wpatc","s_vi","de","rplsb","rplm2","rplmct","rpld0","rpld1","wapo_login_id","wapo_secure_login_id","wapo_groups","wapo_display","wppref","devicetype","s_sess","s_pers","backplane-channel","_chartbeat2","_chartbeat5","client_region","fbuid","fbuname","wapo_fb_token","adsflag","comicsint","galleryplays","homessoldcookie","wapo_provider","washingtonpost_avatar","weather-preroll","wpnisecure","x-wp-split","x-split-override","region_cookie",
"rplpwmode","rplrol","wapo_actmgmt","wapo_az_id","sailthru_hid","sailthru_bid","__gads","osfam","wp_vi","pwamtk","drawbridge_o","drawbridge_test","debug_pwapi_ipdomainon","comscore","rplampr","googleampredirectdebugoverride","iabc","comments_sortorder","drdebugoverride","_ga","ddosdebugoverride","washpost_poe","pwadebugversiononoff","pwahpprocdebug","rplabrfg","rplabtestdebug","wapo_ab_test","rplabscmtr","rplabsectionmeterdebug","rplabuniquevisitdebug","ptvenv","rplpwabt2","rplpwtrk","pwabtestdebug",
"rplpwabt3","rplpwabt4","amp_exp","^fbm_.*","^fbsr_.*","^wordpress_.*","sub$","^wp.*"]};map=map||[];reg=reg||[];for(var i=0;i<cwlobj.cookies.length,value=cwlobj.cookies[i];i++)if("^"==value[0])reg.push(new RegExp(value));else map.push(value);document.__twpCookieMonster__=new document.__CookieMonster__(map,reg)})(document);</script> <script>var TWP_Debug=window.TWP_Debug||{};TWP_Debug.initialTime=new Date;</script> <meta name="object-hash" content="1518808779"/> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge,chrome=1"> <meta charset="utf-8"/> <meta id="viewport" name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0, user-scalable=yes, minimum-scale=0.5, maximum-scale=2.0"/> <meta name="referrer" content="unsafe-url"/> <meta name="keywords" content="Post Keywords"/> <meta name="news_keywords" content="Post Keywords"/> <meta name="twitter:site" value="@WashingtonPost"/> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"> <meta property="og:type" content="article"/> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Washington Post"/> <meta itemprop="mainEntityOfPage" content="True"/> <meta name="magnet" content="harvey"/> <meta property="article:publisher" content="https://www.facebook.com/washingtonpost"> <meta property="fb:app_id" content="41245586762"/> <meta property="fb:admins" content="4403963"/> <meta property="fb:admins" content="500835072"/> <meta property="article:content_tier" content="metered"/> <script type="application/ld+json">
    {
      "@context":"http://schema.org",
      
        
        
        
         
        
            "@type":"ReportageNewsArticle",
        
      
      "mainEntityOfPage":{
        "@type":"WebPage",
        "@id":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"
      },
      "headline":"Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder.",
      
        "description":"A succession of storms adds urgency to climate change and hurricane science.",
      
      
        
        
          "image":["https://www.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_1484w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2017/08/29/National-Enterprise/Images/APTOPIX_Harvey_08040-1da93.jpg?t=20170517"],
        
      
      "datePublished":"2017-08-30T17:51:51.000Z",
      "dateModified":"2017-08-30T17:51:51.000Z",
      "isAccessibleForFree":"False",
      "hasPart":{
        "@type":"WebPageElement",
        "isAccessibleForFree":"False",
        "cssSelector":".paywall"
      },
      "publisher":{
        "@type":"NewsMediaOrganization",
        "name":"The Washington Post",
        "ethicsPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "masthead":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/masthead/",
        "missionCoveragePrioritiesPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "diversityPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "correctionsPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "verificationFactCheckingPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "unnamedSourcesPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "actionableFeedbackPolicy":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "foundingDate":"1877-12-06",
        "ownershipFundingGrants":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/policies-and-standards/",
        "diversityStaffingReport":"http://asne.org/newsroom_diversitysurvey",
        "refLocalNationalRequirements":null,
        "logo":{
          "@type":"ImageObject",
          "url":"https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/thewashingtonpost-black-400x60.png"
        }
      }
    }
  </script> <link rel="manifest" href="/pb/resources/json/desktop-notifications-manifest.json"/> <title>Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder. - The Washington Post</title> <link itemprop="url" rel="canonical" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"/> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"/> <meta property="og:image" content="https://www.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_1484w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2017/08/29/National-Enterprise/Images/APTOPIX_Harvey_08040-1da93.jpg?t=20170517" itemprop="image"/> <meta property="og:title" content="Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder."/> <meta itemprop="description" name="description" content="A succession of storms adds urgency to climate change and hurricane science."/> <meta property="og:description" content="A succession of storms adds urgency to climate change and hurricane science."/> <meta name="robots" content="index,follow"> <meta name="theme" content="normal"> <meta name="audio_url" content=""> <link rel="amphtml" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"/> <link rel="alternate" href="android-app://com.washingtonpost.rainbow/wp-android-rainbow/www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"/> <link rel="alternate" href="android-app://com.washingtonpost.android/wp-android/www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"/> <meta property="article:author" content="https://www.facebook.com/chriscmooney"/> <meta property="author" content="https://www.facebook.com/chriscmooney"/> <meta property="twitter:creator" content="@chriscmooney"/> <!--[if (gt IE 8) | (IEMobile)]><!--> <link href="/pb/gr/c/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/header_fonts/b63f1e9c46.css?_=a0143" rel="stylesheet"/> <!--<![endif]--> <!--[if (lt IE 9) & (!IEMobile)]><link rel="stylesheet" href="//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/css/headerfonts_ie.css?_=201710090909ET"/><![endif]--> <link href="/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/css/5ea0ff903f.css?_=d21a8" rel="stylesheet"/> <link href="/pb/gr/p/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/style.css?_=9b183" rel="stylesheet"/> <style data-id="pb-r-head"></style> <script>window.wp_pb=window.wp_pb||{pageName:"article-business",pageId:"ryDnRS1NelfqIq",contextPath:"/pb",isAdmin:false,layoutEngineName:"off",environment:"production",resourceToken:"201710090909ET",zeusFooter:"",contentFormat:"default",outputType:"default-article",canonical_url:"https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"};</script> <script>window.commercialNode="business";
(function(){try{wp_meta_data=window.wp_meta_data||{};wp_meta_data.platform="pagebuilder";if(!("isPageInitiallyHydrated"in wp_meta_data))wp_meta_data.isPageInitiallyHydrated=true;wp_meta_data.showAds=true;wp_meta_data.isPWA=false;wp_meta_data.showPreRollAds=false;wp_meta_data.isHomepage=false;wp_meta_data.isErrorPage=false;wp_meta_data.isMultimedia=false;wp_meta_data.wt="BlogStory";delete wp_meta_data.facet;wp_meta_data.contentName=["energy-environment"];delete wp_meta_data.contentLength;wp_meta_data.page_id=
["energy-environment42907"];wp_meta_data.meta_date=["1504115511"];wp_meta_data.author=["Chris Mooney"];wp_meta_data.keywords=["Post Keywords"];wp_meta_data.clavis=wp_meta_data.clavis||{};wp_meta_data.clavis.keywords=[];wp_meta_data.clavis.topics=[];wp_meta_data.clavis.ct=[];delete wp_meta_data.destinations;wp_meta_data.hot_topic=[false];delete wp_meta_data.subjects;wp_meta_data.tags="magnet-harvey".split(",");wp_meta_data.tags_for_paywall="magnet-harvey".replace(/[^a-zA-Z0-9-_,]/g,"");delete wp_meta_data.category;
delete wp_meta_data.people_names;delete wp_meta_data.people_positions;delete wp_meta_data.organization_names;delete wp_meta_data.coverage_industrys;delete wp_meta_data.ideology;delete wp_meta_data.addresses;delete wp_meta_data.neighborhoods;delete wp_meta_data.zip_codes;delete wp_meta_data.counties;delete wp_meta_data.venues;delete wp_meta_data.cities;delete wp_meta_data.states;delete wp_meta_data.countries;delete wp_meta_data.breaking_news;wp_meta_data.contentType=["BlogStory"]}catch(e){}})();</script> <script>window.wpAd={"inventory":{"interstitial":{"size":[],"keyvalues":{"ad":"interstitial"}},"leaderboard":{"size":[[728,90],[970,66],[970,250]],"keyvalues":{"pos":"leaderboard"}},"inline_bb":{"size":[[300,250],"fluid"],"sizeOnCondition":{"windowWidth":1250,"size":[620,250]}},"inline_bb_*":{"size":[[300,250],"fluid"],"sizeOnCondition":{"windowWidth":1250,"size":[620,250]}},"flex_ss_bb_hp":{"size":[[336,850],[336,280],[160,600],[300,250],[300,600],[300,1050]]},"flex_ss_bb_hp_*":{"size":[[336,850],[336,280],
[160,600],[300,250],[300,600],[300,1050]]},"flex_bb_hp":{"size":[[336,850],[336,280],[300,600],[300,1050],[300,250]]},"tiffany_tile":{"size":[[200,60],[184,90]],"keyvalues":{"ad":["tiffany_tile"]}},"tiffany_tile_*":{"size":[[200,60],[184,90]]},"brandconnect_front":{"size":[[1,8],"fluid"]},"bc_pb_homepage":{"size":[[1,8],"fluid"]},"336x60":{"size":[[336,60]],"keyvalues":{"ad":["336x60"]}},"336x35_top":{"size":[[336,35]],"keyvalues":{"ad":["336x35"]}},"marketing_2":{"size":[[1,1]]},"marketwatch":{"size":[[1,
1]]},"twittermodule":{"size":[[1,1]]},"88x31":{"size":[[88,31]]},"bigbox":{"size":[[300,250],"fluid"]},"bigbox_*":{"size":[[300,250],"fluid"]},"bigbox_gallery":{"size":[[300,250]]},"context_notes":{"size":[[1,1]]},"enterprise":{"size":[[1,1],[620,250],[728,90]]},"enterprise_*":{"size":[[1,1],[620,250],[728,90]]},"mob_bigbox":{"size":[[300,250],[300,600],"fluid"]},"mob_bigbox_*":{"size":[[300,250],"fluid"]},"fixedBottom":{"size":[[320,50],[300,50]]},"pushdown":{"size":[[1,1],[970,66],[970,90],[728,
90],[970,250]]},"bc_bigbox":{"size":[[300,250]]},"lily_inline":{"size":[[300,250],[620,250],"fluid"],"sizeOnCondition":{"windowWidth":1250,"size":[970,250]}},"lily_inline_*":{"size":[[300,250],[620,250],"fluid"],"sizeOnCondition":{"windowWidth":1250,"size":[970,250]}},"brandconnect_lily":{"size":["fluid"]},"lily_mob_inline":{"size":[[300,250],[300,600],"fluid"]},"lily_mob_inline_*":{"size":[[300,250],"fluid"]},"polly_article":{"size":[[1,1]]},"postrecommends":{"size":[[1,1]]}},"exclusionsKeyWords":{"natural_disaster":["deepwater",
"oil spill","shell","exxon","citgo","bp","chevron","hess","sunoco","disaster","fire","explosion","oil","coal","death","dead","quake","earthquake","tsunami","tornado","hurricane","flood","bed bug","infestation","gas","tropical storm","Irma","Harvey"],"human_disaster":["Weinstein","massacre","oreilly","Ailes","o'reilly","fox news","abuse","death","trafficking","dead","gunshot","murderer","porn","sex tape","sexting","sexual abuse","molestation","assault","child abuse","sex abuse","ISIS","ISIL","Islamic State",
"Al Qaeda","Syria","Syrian","Assad","shooter","shooting","migrants","aylan kurdi","refugee crisis","drown","shoot","vatican","spanair","aground","rescue","attack","disaster","explosion","war","hostage","terror","terrorist","bomb","blast","mining","miner","violence","riot","crash","9/11","sept. 11","september 11","behead","United 93","pistorius","ebola","rape","rapist","amtrak","derailment","benghazi","misconduct"],"financial_crisis":["corrupt","lawsuit","goldman","aig","foreclosure","enron","sec",
"mortgage","Insurance","health","bank","wall street","protest","labor strike","union strike","labor issue","union issue","teacher strike","teachers strike","election"],"inappropriate":["porn","deepwater","gambling","sex","alcohol","pornography"]},"posOnCommericalNode":{"washingtonpost.com":{"pos":{"leaderboard":{"start":"02/17/2018 00:00 EDT","end":"02/19/2018 23:59 EDT"},"flex_bb_hp":{"start":"01/30/2018 00:00 EDT","end":"12/31/2018 23:59 EDT"},"tiffany_tile":{"start":"02/09/2018 00:00 EDT","end":"12/31/2018 23:59 EDT"},
"tiffany_tile_2":{"start":"02/09/2018 00:00 EDT","end":"12/31/2018 23:59 EDT"},"pushdown":{"start":"09/12/2017 00:00 EDT","end":"09/12/2017 23:59 EDT"}}},"powerpost":{"pos":{"tiffany_tile":{"start":"01/01/2017 00:00 EDT","end":"07/09/2017 00:00 EDT"}}},"powerpost/article":{"pos":{"tiffany_tile":{"start":"01/01/2017 00:00 EDT","end":"07/09/2017 00:00 EDT"}}}}};</script> <script src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/ad/zeus/wp-ad.min.js" async></script> <meta name="apple-itunes-app" content="app-id=938922398, app-argument=https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"/> <link rel="manifest" href="/pb/resources/json/manifest.json"/> <script src="/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/load_immediately/cd57f7dcfb.js?_=7da5f"></script> <script>wp_import.valor(true);</script> <script>window.head_conf={head:"TWPHead"};</script> <script>(function(){TWP=typeof TWP=="undefined"?{}:TWP;TWP.Data=typeof TWP.Data=="undefined"?{}:TWP.Data;TWP.Data["Tracking"]={init:function(){this.props={};this.props.platform="pagebuilder";this.props.site="www.washingtonpost.com";this.props.page_type="";this.props.page_name="business:blog:energy-environment - 42907 - 20170830 - katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder";this.props.section="business";this.props.channel="wp - business";this.props.subsection=
"business";this.props.hierarchy="business|blog";this.props.content_type="blog";this.props.story_type="";this.props.headline="Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder.";this.props.author="Chris Mooney";this.props.source="The Washington Post";this.props.content_id="energy-environment42907";this.props.page_num="";this.props.columnname="";this.props.blogname="energy-environment";this.props.published="";this.props.news_or_commercial="News";this.props.commercial_node=
"/business";this.props.content_category="Business";this.props.sectionfront="";this.props.track_scrolling=true;this.props.inline_elements=""}};TWP.Data["Tracking"].init()})();</script> <script>(function($){window.pbExternalResourcesLoaded=window.pbExternalResourcesLoaded||new Array;window.pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups=window.pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups||new Array;var version="";var env="production";var fileList=[];fileList.push("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/conf-production/b5411285f6.js?_\x3d81d55");pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"conf-production","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/conf/production/conf.js?_\x3d81d55");
fileList.push("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/modal-css/938c258067.css?_\x3d2ffa5");pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"modal-css","fileType":"css"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/identity-management/modal.css?_\x3d2ffa5");fileList.push("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/identity-management/da39a3ee5e.js?_\x3db847a");fileList.push("https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/pwapi/prod/wpPwapi1-min.js?token\x3d201706011309EST");
fileList.push("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/identity-management/c4d7fa1f35.js?_\x3db847a");pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"identity-management","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/pwapi/prod/wpPwapi1-min.js?token\x3d201706011309EST");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/identity-management/util-user-2.0.0.js?_\x3df738c");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/identity-management/util.identity-management-1.2.0.js?_\x3d9d504");
fileList.push("https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/analytics/latest/main.js?token\x3d201710090909ET");var fileList2=[];fileList.push("//www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/advertising/pseudo-static/identity-retargeting.js");var country_cookie=document.cookie.match(/wp_country=([^;]+)/)?RegExp.$1:null;if(country_cookie&&country_cookie!="US"){fileList.unshift();pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"eu-cookie-banner","fileType":"js"})}if(typeof $.jqm==="undefined"){fileList.unshift("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/jqmodal/7a5b554023.js?_\x3d26a28");
pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"jqmodal","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/jqModal.js?_\x3d26a28")}if(typeof $.cookie==="undefined"){fileList.unshift("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/jquery-cookie/4cc3c1bef0.js?_\x3db8874");pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"jquery-cookie","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/plugins/plugin.jquery.cookie-1.0.0.js?_\x3db8874")}if(typeof jQuery===
"undefined"){fileList.unshift("//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/jquery/c85562b39d.js?_\x3db45ba");pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"jquery","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/jquery/latest/jquery.js?_\x3db45ba")}function loadResources(){wp_import.valor(true);var r=new ResourceBundle("pb-r-identity");$.each(fileList,function(key,value){r.push(value)});var r2=new ResourceBundle("pb-r-retargeting");
$.each(fileList2,function(key,value){r2.push(value)});$(window.document).trigger("twp.identity.load.start");r.trigger().always(function(){if(window.performance&&typeof performance.mark==="function")window.performance.mark("ResourceBundle pb-r-identity");$(window.document).trigger("twp.identity.load.complete")}).fail(function(a,b){try{console.error(a,b)}catch(e){}});ResourceBundle.when("pb-r-identity").then(function(){r2.trigger("pb-r-retargeting",true)}).fail(function(a,b){try{console.error(a,b)}catch(e){}})}
if(typeof window.ResourceBundle==="undefined"){var jsHeadJs="//www.washingtonpost.com/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/wp_import/1aa37c2c30.js?_\x3dbf2b9";pbTwpGlobalResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"wp_import","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/wp_import/wp_import.js?_\x3dbf2b9");var jsscript=document.createElement("script");jsscript.onload=jsscript.onreadystatechange=function(){if(this.readyState&&this.readyState!="complete"&&this.readyState!=
"loaded")return;loadResources()};jsscript.src=jsHeadJs;var jssib=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];jssib.parentNode.insertBefore(jsscript,jssib)}else document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){loadResources()})})(jQuery);</script> <script>(function(){if(window.BOOMR&&window.BOOMR.version)return;var dom,doc,where,iframe=document.createElement("iframe"),win=window;function boomerangSaveLoadTime(e){win.BOOMR_onload=e&&e.timeStamp||(new Date).getTime()}if(win.addEventListener)win.addEventListener("load",boomerangSaveLoadTime,false);else if(win.attachEvent)win.attachEvent("onload",boomerangSaveLoadTime);iframe.src="javascript:false";iframe.title="";iframe.role="presentation";(iframe.frameElement||iframe).style.cssText="width:0;height:0;border:0;display:none;";
where=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];where.parentNode.insertBefore(iframe,where);try{doc=iframe.contentWindow.document}catch(e){dom=document.domain;iframe.src="javascript:var d\x3ddocument.open();d.domain\x3d'"+dom+"';void(0);";doc=iframe.contentWindow.document}doc.open()._l=function(){var js=this.createElement("script");if(dom)this.domain=dom;js.id="boomr-if-as";js.src="https://c.go-mpulse.net/boomerang/"+"W8234-EWWKH-SQWJU-EAC6K-7AE5Z";BOOMR_lstart=(new Date).getTime();this.body.appendChild(js)};
doc.write('\x3cbody onload\x3d"document._l();"\x3e');doc.close()})();</script> <script>window.NREUM||(NREUM={}),__nr_require=function(t,n,e){function r(e){if(!n[e]){var o=n[e]={exports:{}};t[e][0].call(o.exports,function(n){var o=t[e][1][n];return r(o||n)},o,o.exports)}return n[e].exports}if("function"==typeof __nr_require)return __nr_require;for(var o=0;o<e.length;o++)r(e[o]);return r}({1:[function(t,n,e){function r(t){try{s.console&&console.log(t)}catch(n){}}var o,i=t("ee"),a=t(15),s={};try{o=localStorage.getItem("__nr_flags").split(","),console&&"function"==typeof console.log&&(s.console=
!0,o.indexOf("dev")!==-1&&(s.dev=!0),o.indexOf("nr_dev")!==-1&&(s.nrDev=!0))}catch(c){}s.nrDev&&i.on("internal-error",function(t){r(t.stack)}),s.dev&&i.on("fn-err",function(t,n,e){r(e.stack)}),s.dev&&(r("NR AGENT IN DEVELOPMENT MODE"),r("flags: "+a(s,function(t,n){return t}).join(", ")))},{}],2:[function(t,n,e){function r(t,n,e,r,o){try{d?d-=1:i("err",[o||new UncaughtException(t,n,e)])}catch(s){try{i("ierr",[s,c.now(),!0])}catch(u){}}return"function"==typeof f&&f.apply(this,a(arguments))}function UncaughtException(t,
n,e){this.message=t||"Uncaught error with no additional information",this.sourceURL=n,this.line=e}function o(t){i("err",[t,c.now()])}var i=t("handle"),a=t(16),s=t("ee"),c=t("loader"),f=window.onerror,u=!1,d=0;c.features.err=!0,t(1),window.onerror=r;try{throw new Error;}catch(l){"stack"in l&&(t(8),t(7),"addEventListener"in window&&t(5),c.xhrWrappable&&t(9),u=!0)}s.on("fn-start",function(t,n,e){u&&(d+=1)}),s.on("fn-err",function(t,n,e){u&&(this.thrown=!0,o(e))}),s.on("fn-end",function(){u&&!this.thrown&&
d>0&&(d-=1)}),s.on("internal-error",function(t){i("ierr",[t,c.now(),!0])})},{}],3:[function(t,n,e){t("loader").features.ins=!0},{}],4:[function(t,n,e){function r(t){}if(window.performance&&window.performance.timing&&window.performance.getEntriesByType){var o=t("ee"),i=t("handle"),a=t(8),s=t(7),c="learResourceTimings",f="addEventListener",u="resourcetimingbufferfull",d="bstResource",l="resource",p="-start",h="-end",m="fn"+p,w="fn"+h,v="bstTimer",y="pushState",g=t("loader");g.features.stn=!0,t(6);var b=
NREUM.o.EV;o.on(m,function(t,n){var e=t[0];e instanceof b&&(this.bstStart=g.now())}),o.on(w,function(t,n){var e=t[0];e instanceof b&&i("bst",[e,n,this.bstStart,g.now()])}),a.on(m,function(t,n,e){this.bstStart=g.now(),this.bstType=e}),a.on(w,function(t,n){i(v,[n,this.bstStart,g.now(),this.bstType])}),s.on(m,function(){this.bstStart=g.now()}),s.on(w,function(t,n){i(v,[n,this.bstStart,g.now(),"requestAnimationFrame"])}),o.on(y+p,function(t){this.time=g.now(),this.startPath=location.pathname+location.hash}),
o.on(y+h,function(t){i("bstHist",[location.pathname+location.hash,this.startPath,this.time])}),f in window.performance&&(window.performance["c"+c]?window.performance[f](u,function(t){i(d,[window.performance.getEntriesByType(l)]),window.performance["c"+c]()},!1):window.performance[f]("webkit"+u,function(t){i(d,[window.performance.getEntriesByType(l)]),window.performance["webkitC"+c]()},!1)),document[f]("scroll",r,{passive:!0}),document[f]("keypress",r,!1),document[f]("click",r,!1)}},{}],5:[function(t,
n,e){function r(t){for(var n=t;n&&!n.hasOwnProperty(u);)n=Object.getPrototypeOf(n);n&&o(n)}function o(t){s.inPlace(t,[u,d],"-",i)}function i(t,n){return t[1]}var a=t("ee").get("events"),s=t(18)(a,!0),c=t("gos"),f=XMLHttpRequest,u="addEventListener",d="removeEventListener";n.exports=a,"getPrototypeOf"in Object?(r(document),r(window),r(f.prototype)):f.prototype.hasOwnProperty(u)&&(o(window),o(f.prototype)),a.on(u+"-start",function(t,n){var e=t[1],r=c(e,"nr@wrapped",function(){function t(){if("function"==
typeof e.handleEvent)return e.handleEvent.apply(e,arguments)}var n={object:t,"function":e}[typeof e];return n?s(n,"fn-",null,n.name||"anonymous"):e});this.wrapped=t[1]=r}),a.on(d+"-start",function(t){t[1]=this.wrapped||t[1]})},{}],6:[function(t,n,e){var r=t("ee").get("history"),o=t(18)(r);n.exports=r,o.inPlace(window.history,["pushState","replaceState"],"-")},{}],7:[function(t,n,e){var r=t("ee").get("raf"),o=t(18)(r),i="equestAnimationFrame";n.exports=r,o.inPlace(window,["r"+i,"mozR"+i,"webkitR"+
i,"msR"+i],"raf-"),r.on("raf-start",function(t){t[0]=o(t[0],"fn-")})},{}],8:[function(t,n,e){function r(t,n,e){t[0]=a(t[0],"fn-",null,e)}function o(t,n,e){this.method=e,this.timerDuration=isNaN(t[1])?0:+t[1],t[0]=a(t[0],"fn-",this,e)}var i=t("ee").get("timer"),a=t(18)(i),s="setTimeout",c="setInterval",f="clearTimeout",u="-start",d="-";n.exports=i,a.inPlace(window,[s,"setImmediate"],s+d),a.inPlace(window,[c],c+d),a.inPlace(window,[f,"clearImmediate"],f+d),i.on(c+u,r),i.on(s+u,o)},{}],9:[function(t,
n,e){function r(t,n){d.inPlace(n,["onreadystatechange"],"fn-",s)}function o(){var t=this,n=u.context(t);t.readyState>3&&!n.resolved&&(n.resolved=!0,u.emit("xhr-resolved",[],t)),d.inPlace(t,y,"fn-",s)}function i(t){g.push(t),h&&(x?x.then(a):w?w(a):(E=-E,O.data=E))}function a(){for(var t=0;t<g.length;t++)r([],g[t]);g.length&&(g=[])}function s(t,n){return n}function c(t,n){for(var e in t)n[e]=t[e];return n}t(5);var f=t("ee"),u=f.get("xhr"),d=t(18)(u),l=NREUM.o,p=l.XHR,h=l.MO,m=l.PR,w=l.SI,v="readystatechange",
y=["onload","onerror","onabort","onloadstart","onloadend","onprogress","ontimeout"],g=[];n.exports=u;var b=window.XMLHttpRequest=function(t){var n=new p(t);try{u.emit("new-xhr",[n],n),n.addEventListener(v,o,!1)}catch(e){try{u.emit("internal-error",[e])}catch(r){}}return n};if(c(p,b),b.prototype=p.prototype,d.inPlace(b.prototype,["open","send"],"-xhr-",s),u.on("send-xhr-start",function(t,n){r(t,n),i(n)}),u.on("open-xhr-start",r),h){var x=m&&m.resolve();if(!w&&!m){var E=1,O=document.createTextNode(E);
(new h(a)).observe(O,{characterData:!0})}}else f.on("fn-end",function(t){t[0]&&t[0].type===v||a()})},{}],10:[function(t,n,e){function r(t){var n=this.params,e=this.metrics;if(!this.ended){this.ended=!0;for(var r=0;r<d;r++)t.removeEventListener(u[r],this.listener,!1);if(!n.aborted){if(e.duration=a.now()-this.startTime,4===t.readyState){n.status=t.status;var i=o(t,this.lastSize);if(i&&(e.rxSize=i),this.sameOrigin){var c=t.getResponseHeader("X-NewRelic-App-Data");c&&(n.cat=c.split(", ").pop())}}else n.status=
0;e.cbTime=this.cbTime,f.emit("xhr-done",[t],t),s("xhr",[n,e,this.startTime])}}}function o(t,n){var e=t.responseType;if("json"===e&&null!==n)return n;var r="arraybuffer"===e||"blob"===e||"json"===e?t.response:t.responseText;return h(r)}function i(t,n){var e=c(n),r=t.params;r.host=e.hostname+":"+e.port,r.pathname=e.pathname,t.sameOrigin=e.sameOrigin}var a=t("loader");if(a.xhrWrappable){var s=t("handle"),c=t(11),f=t("ee"),u=["load","error","abort","timeout"],d=u.length,l=t("id"),p=t(14),h=t(13),m=window.XMLHttpRequest;
a.features.xhr=!0,t(9),f.on("new-xhr",function(t){var n=this;n.totalCbs=0,n.called=0,n.cbTime=0,n.end=r,n.ended=!1,n.xhrGuids={},n.lastSize=null,p&&(p>34||p<10)||window.opera||t.addEventListener("progress",function(t){n.lastSize=t.loaded},!1)}),f.on("open-xhr-start",function(t){this.params={method:t[0]},i(this,t[1]),this.metrics={}}),f.on("open-xhr-end",function(t,n){"loader_config"in NREUM&&"xpid"in NREUM.loader_config&&this.sameOrigin&&n.setRequestHeader("X-NewRelic-ID",NREUM.loader_config.xpid)}),
f.on("send-xhr-start",function(t,n){var e=this.metrics,r=t[0],o=this;if(e&&r){var i=h(r);i&&(e.txSize=i)}this.startTime=a.now(),this.listener=function(t){try{"abort"===t.type&&(o.params.aborted=!0),("load"!==t.type||o.called===o.totalCbs&&(o.onloadCalled||"function"!=typeof n.onload))&&o.end(n)}catch(e){try{f.emit("internal-error",[e])}catch(r){}}};for(var s=0;s<d;s++)n.addEventListener(u[s],this.listener,!1)}),f.on("xhr-cb-time",function(t,n,e){this.cbTime+=t,n?this.onloadCalled=!0:this.called+=
1,this.called!==this.totalCbs||!this.onloadCalled&&"function"==typeof e.onload||this.end(e)}),f.on("xhr-load-added",function(t,n){var e=""+l(t)+!!n;this.xhrGuids&&!this.xhrGuids[e]&&(this.xhrGuids[e]=!0,this.totalCbs+=1)}),f.on("xhr-load-removed",function(t,n){var e=""+l(t)+!!n;this.xhrGuids&&this.xhrGuids[e]&&(delete this.xhrGuids[e],this.totalCbs-=1)}),f.on("addEventListener-end",function(t,n){n instanceof m&&"load"===t[0]&&f.emit("xhr-load-added",[t[1],t[2]],n)}),f.on("removeEventListener-end",
function(t,n){n instanceof m&&"load"===t[0]&&f.emit("xhr-load-removed",[t[1],t[2]],n)}),f.on("fn-start",function(t,n,e){n instanceof m&&("onload"===e&&(this.onload=!0),("load"===(t[0]&&t[0].type)||this.onload)&&(this.xhrCbStart=a.now()))}),f.on("fn-end",function(t,n){this.xhrCbStart&&f.emit("xhr-cb-time",[a.now()-this.xhrCbStart,this.onload,n],n)})}},{}],11:[function(t,n,e){n.exports=function(t){var n=document.createElement("a"),e=window.location,r={};n.href=t,r.port=n.port;var o=n.href.split("://");
!r.port&&o[1]&&(r.port=o[1].split("/")[0].split("@").pop().split(":")[1]),r.port&&"0"!==r.port||(r.port="https"===o[0]?"443":"80"),r.hostname=n.hostname||e.hostname,r.pathname=n.pathname,r.protocol=o[0],"/"!==r.pathname.charAt(0)&&(r.pathname="/"+r.pathname);var i=!n.protocol||":"===n.protocol||n.protocol===e.protocol,a=n.hostname===document.domain&&n.port===e.port;return r.sameOrigin=i&&(!n.hostname||a),r}},{}],12:[function(t,n,e){function r(){}function o(t,n,e){return function(){return i(t,[f.now()].concat(s(arguments)),
n?null:this,e),n?void 0:this}}var i=t("handle"),a=t(15),s=t(16),c=t("ee").get("tracer"),f=t("loader"),u=NREUM;"undefined"==typeof window.newrelic&&(newrelic=u);var d=["setPageViewName","setCustomAttribute","setErrorHandler","finished","addToTrace","inlineHit","addRelease"],l="api-",p=l+"ixn-";a(d,function(t,n){u[n]=o(l+n,!0,"api")}),u.addPageAction=o(l+"addPageAction",!0),u.setCurrentRouteName=o(l+"routeName",!0),n.exports=newrelic,u.interaction=function(){return(new r).get()};var h=r.prototype={createTracer:function(t,
n){var e={},r=this,o="function"==typeof n;return i(p+"tracer",[f.now(),t,e],r),function(){if(c.emit((o?"":"no-")+"fn-start",[f.now(),r,o],e),o)try{return n.apply(this,arguments)}finally{c.emit("fn-end",[f.now()],e)}}}};a("setName,setAttribute,save,ignore,onEnd,getContext,end,get".split(","),function(t,n){h[n]=o(p+n)}),newrelic.noticeError=function(t){"string"==typeof t&&(t=new Error(t)),i("err",[t,f.now()])}},{}],13:[function(t,n,e){n.exports=function(t){if("string"==typeof t&&t.length)return t.length;
if("object"==typeof t){if("undefined"!=typeof ArrayBuffer&&t instanceof ArrayBuffer&&t.byteLength)return t.byteLength;if("undefined"!=typeof Blob&&t instanceof Blob&&t.size)return t.size;if(!("undefined"!=typeof FormData&&t instanceof FormData))try{return JSON.stringify(t).length}catch(n){return}}}},{}],14:[function(t,n,e){var r=0,o=navigator.userAgent.match(/Firefox[\/\s](\d+\.\d+)/);o&&(r=+o[1]),n.exports=r},{}],15:[function(t,n,e){function r(t,n){var e=[],r="",i=0;for(r in t)o.call(t,r)&&(e[i]=
n(r,t[r]),i+=1);return e}var o=Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty;n.exports=r},{}],16:[function(t,n,e){function r(t,n,e){n||(n=0),"undefined"==typeof e&&(e=t?t.length:0);for(var r=-1,o=e-n||0,i=Array(o<0?0:o);++r<o;)i[r]=t[n+r];return i}n.exports=r},{}],17:[function(t,n,e){n.exports={exists:"undefined"!=typeof window.performance&&window.performance.timing&&"undefined"!=typeof window.performance.timing.navigationStart}},{}],18:[function(t,n,e){function r(t){return!(t&&t instanceof Function&&t.apply&&
!t[a])}var o=t("ee"),i=t(16),a="nr@original",s=Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty,c=!1;n.exports=function(t,n){function e(t,n,e,o){function nrWrapper(){var r,a,s,c;try{a=this,r=i(arguments),s="function"==typeof e?e(r,a):e||{}}catch(f){l([f,"",[r,a,o],s])}u(n+"start",[r,a,o],s);try{return c=t.apply(a,r)}catch(d){throw u(n+"err",[r,a,d],s),d;}finally{u(n+"end",[r,a,c],s)}}return r(t)?t:(n||(n=""),nrWrapper[a]=t,d(t,nrWrapper),nrWrapper)}function f(t,n,o,i){o||(o="");var a,s,c,f="-"===o.charAt(0);for(c=
0;c<n.length;c++)s=n[c],a=t[s],r(a)||(t[s]=e(a,f?s+o:o,i,s))}function u(e,r,o){if(!c||n){var i=c;c=!0;try{t.emit(e,r,o,n)}catch(a){l([a,e,r,o])}c=i}}function d(t,n){if(Object.defineProperty&&Object.keys)try{var e=Object.keys(t);return e.forEach(function(e){Object.defineProperty(n,e,{get:function(){return t[e]},set:function(n){return t[e]=n,n}})}),n}catch(r){l([r])}for(var o in t)s.call(t,o)&&(n[o]=t[o]);return n}function l(n){try{t.emit("internal-error",n)}catch(e){}}return t||(t=o),e.inPlace=f,e.flag=
a,e}},{}],ee:[function(t,n,e){function r(){}function o(t){function n(t){return t&&t instanceof r?t:t?c(t,s,i):i()}function e(e,r,o,i){if(!l.aborted||i){t&&t(e,r,o);for(var a=n(o),s=h(e),c=s.length,f=0;f<c;f++)s[f].apply(a,r);var d=u[y[e]];return d&&d.push([g,e,r,a]),a}}function p(t,n){v[t]=h(t).concat(n)}function h(t){return v[t]||[]}function m(t){return d[t]=d[t]||o(e)}function w(t,n){f(t,function(t,e){n=n||"feature",y[e]=n,n in u||(u[n]=[])})}var v={},y={},g={on:p,emit:e,get:m,listeners:h,context:n,
buffer:w,abort:a,aborted:!1};return g}function i(){return new r}function a(){(u.api||u.feature)&&(l.aborted=!0,u=l.backlog={})}var s="nr@context",c=t("gos"),f=t(15),u={},d={},l=n.exports=o();l.backlog=u},{}],gos:[function(t,n,e){function r(t,n,e){if(o.call(t,n))return t[n];var r=e();if(Object.defineProperty&&Object.keys)try{return Object.defineProperty(t,n,{value:r,writable:!0,enumerable:!1}),r}catch(i){}return t[n]=r,r}var o=Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty;n.exports=r},{}],handle:[function(t,n,e){function r(t,
n,e,r){o.buffer([t],r),o.emit(t,n,e)}var o=t("ee").get("handle");n.exports=r,r.ee=o},{}],id:[function(t,n,e){function r(t){var n=typeof t;return!t||"object"!==n&&"function"!==n?-1:t===window?0:a(t,i,function(){return o++})}var o=1,i="nr@id",a=t("gos");n.exports=r},{}],loader:[function(t,n,e){function r(){if(!x++){var t=b.info=NREUM.info,n=l.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];if(setTimeout(u.abort,3E4),!(t&&t.licenseKey&&t.applicationID&&n))return u.abort();f(y,function(n,e){t[n]||(t[n]=e)}),c("mark",
["onload",a()+b.offset],null,"api");var e=l.createElement("script");e.src="https://"+t.agent,n.parentNode.insertBefore(e,n)}}function o(){"complete"===l.readyState&&i()}function i(){c("mark",["domContent",a()+b.offset],null,"api")}function a(){return E.exists&&performance.now?Math.round(performance.now()):(s=Math.max((new Date).getTime(),s))-b.offset}var s=(new Date).getTime(),c=t("handle"),f=t(15),u=t("ee"),d=window,l=d.document,p="addEventListener",h="attachEvent",m=d.XMLHttpRequest,w=m&&m.prototype;
NREUM.o={ST:setTimeout,SI:d.setImmediate,CT:clearTimeout,XHR:m,REQ:d.Request,EV:d.Event,PR:d.Promise,MO:d.MutationObserver};var v=""+location,y={beacon:"bam.nr-data.net",errorBeacon:"bam.nr-data.net",agent:"js-agent.newrelic.com/nr-1044.min.js"},g=m&&w&&w[p]&&!/CriOS/.test(navigator.userAgent),b=n.exports={offset:s,now:a,origin:v,features:{},xhrWrappable:g};t(12),l[p]?(l[p]("DOMContentLoaded",i,!1),d[p]("load",r,!1)):(l[h]("onreadystatechange",o),d[h]("onload",r)),c("mark",["firstbyte",s],null,"api");
var x=0,E=t(17)},{}]},{},["loader",2,10,4,3]);NREUM.info={beacon:"bam.nr-data.net",errorBeacon:"bam.nr-data.net",licenseKey:"ce992986c8",applicationID:"91618238",sa:1};</script> <script>if(typeof newrelic=="object"){newrelic.setCustomAttribute("site","www.washingtonpost.com");newrelic.setCustomAttribute("rawUserAgent",navigator.userAgent);if(window.wp_pb&&wp_pb.pageName)newrelic.setCustomAttribute("pbPageName",wp_pb.pageName)};</script> <script>window.pbExternalResourcesLoaded=window.pbExternalResourcesLoaded||new Array;window.pbHeadResourceGroups=window.pbHeadResourceGroups||new Array;pbHeadResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"css","fileType":"css"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/normalize.css?_\x3d6a9e1");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/assets/fonts/custom/latest/css/icons.css?_\x3df2022");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/pbCore.css?_\x3d085a8");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/voltron-v2.css?_\x3ddfe15");
pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/bootstrap-cols.css?_\x3d3b7b6");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/refresh.css?_\x3d9949c");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/loadAsync.css?_\x3ddd2a8");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/homepage-layout.css?_\x3deaefa");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/article-layout.css?_\x3df7b59");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/inline-content.css?_\x3d9f7b2");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/css/flex-item.css?_\x3d085a8");
pbHeadResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"pageResources","name":"style.css","fileType":"css"});pbHeadResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"load_immediately","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/jquery/latest/jquery.js?_\x3db45ba");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/wp_import/wp_import.js?_\x3dbf2b9");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/loadAsync.js?_\x3def538");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/event-controller.v2.js?_\x3d7ea6e");
pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/event-queue.js?_\x3df2c13");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/pbCore.article.js?_\x3d8d21e");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/utils/pbStaticMethodsEssentials.js?_\x3d9afe0");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/utils/mobile-detection.js?_\x3d8c659");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/utils/console/console.noop.js?_\x3d8d21e");
pbHeadResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"load_async","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/polyfills.min.js?_\x3db72b3");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/utils/pbStaticMethodsAsync.js?_\x3d9afe0");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/utils/mobile-detection-classes.js?_\x3dc311c");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/plugins/plugin.jquery.cookie-1.0.0.js?_\x3db8874");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/cookie-sync.min.js?_\x3dbd27d");
pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/plugins/plugin.jquery.in-viewport-1.0.0.js?_\x3d26cc0");pbHeadResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"headjs","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/noop.js?_\x3dd47ff");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/article-layout-headjs.js?_\x3d26cc0");pbHeadResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"pageResources","name":"head.js","fileType":"js"});</script> </head> <body class="pb-theme-normal pb-full-fluid" data-no_ads="false"> <div style="width: 1px !important; height: 1px !important; position: absolute !important; left: -10000px !important; top: -1000px !important;" class="pub_300x250 pub_300x250m pub_728x90 text-ad textAd text_ad text_ads text-ads text-ad-links" id="wp-adb-c"></div> <div id="pb-f-a"></div> <div id="pb-root" class=""><section id="top-furniture" class="col-xs-12 layout"><div id="f0Oz8duNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-page-header-v2" moat-id="page/header-v2|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="page/header-v2" data-pb-fingerprint="0fGmHEvNlqs" id="f0uSitlNelfqIq"> <!--[if IE 9]><style>#main-sections-nav.subNavigation{width:475px !important}#main-sections-nav{left:-250px !important;width:315px !important}#main-sections-nav-inner{position:absolute !important}#main-sections-nav.subNavigation #main-sections-nav-inner{width:550px !important;overflow-x:hidden !important}#main-sections-nav.subNavigation{width:470px !important}</style><![endif]--> <!--[if IE 9]><div id="page" class="ie ie9 "><![endif]--> <!--[if IE 8]><div id="page" class="ie ie8 "><![endif]--> <!--[if !IE]><!--> <div id="page" class="nie "> <!--<![endif]--> <header id="wp-header" class="site-header fixed "> <nav id="nav-bar" class="top-nav" role="navigation"> <div id="logo-in-nav" class=" nav-display-show " itemprop="publisher" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/Organization"> <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com" class="wp-logo-link" itemprop="logo" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ImageObject"> <img width="181" class="main-logo" src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/thewashingtonpost-white-2x.png" alt="The Washington Post"/> <meta itemprop="url" content="https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/thewashingtonpost-white-2x.png"> <meta itemprop="width" content="200"> <meta itemprop="height" content="40"> <div class="tagline-wrapper"> <span class="header-tagline">Democracy Dies in Darkness</span> </div> </a> <meta itemprop="name" content="washingtonpost"/> </div> <div class="main-navigation row"> <div class="col-xs-7 col-md-7 col-lg-7"> <ul class="buttons-inline"> <li class="search-form-item hidden-xs"> <form id="search-form" method="get" class="search" action="//www.washingtonpost.com/newssearch/"> <input id="search-field" autocomplete="off" name="query" type="text" class="form-control closed" placeholder="Search"/> <i id="search-btn" class="fa fa-search closed"></i> </form> </li> <li class="hidden-xs"> <a href="#" id="section-menu-btn" class="button section-menu-btn sections"> Sections <i class="fa fa-bars"></i> </a> </li> <li class="mobile-nav-button visible-xs"> <a href="#" class="section-menu-btn"> <i class="fa fa-bars mobile-hamburger-ic" id="mobile-hamburger-ic"></i> </a> </li> <li id="section-menu-home" class="menu hidden-xs hide"> <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/?tid=tst_homelink">Home</a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="col-xs-5 col-md-5 col-lg-5"> <div class="mobile-settings-button"> <a href="#" id="settings-nav-btn"></a> </div> <div class="sign-up-buttons"> <ul class="button-group" id="logged-in-status"> <li id="nav-subscribe" class="hidden"> <a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/acquisition/?nid=top_pb_subscribe&promo=o3&oscode=RPWH&destination=https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/&tid=nav_subscribe_logged_out" class="button"> <span>Subscribe</span> </a> <hr class="separator"/> </li> <li id="nav-user" class="hidden hidden-xs" data-show-identity="true" data-menu="user-menu"> <a class="button"> <span class="username">Username</span> </a> </li> <li class="nav-sign-in hidden"> <a id="sign-in-link" href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/loginregistration/index.html?tid=nav_sign_in" class="button"> <span class="username">Sign In</span> </a> <hr class="separator"/> </li> <div class="visible-xs"> <ul class="site-info"> <li class="account-menu hidden"><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/profile/#/?destination=https://www.washingtonpost.com/?refresh=true&tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Account</a></li> <li class="account-menu hidden"><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/profile/#/?destination=https://www.washingtonpost.com/?refresh=true&tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Profile</a></li> <li><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/newsletters?tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Newsletters &amp; Alerts</a></li> <li><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/gift?promo=g_d&tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Gift Subscriptions</a></li> <li><a href="http://help.washingtonpost.com/ics/support/ticketnewwizard.asp?tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Contact Us</a></li> <li><a href="http://help.washingtonpost.com/ics/support/KBSplash.asp?tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Help Desk</a></li> </ul> </div> </ul> </div> <div id="slug_88x31" data-ad-type="88x31" style="display:none;"></div> </div> </div> </nav> <div id="user-menu" class="nav-menu hidden"> <ul> <li id="nav-subscribe" class="hidden"> <a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/acquisition/?nid=top_pb_subscribe&promo=o5&oscode=RPWH&destination=https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/&tid=nav_subscribe_logged_in" class="button"> <span>Subscribe</span> </a> <hr class="separator"/> </li> </ul> <ul class="user-info"></ul> <ul class="site-info"> <li class="account-menu hidden"><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/profile/#/?destination=https://www.washingtonpost.com/?refresh=true&tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Account</a></li> <li class="account-menu hidden"><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/profile/#/?destination=https://www.washingtonpost.com/?refresh=true&tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Profile</a></li> <li><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/newsletters?tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Newsletters &amp; Alerts</a></li> <li><a href="https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/gift?promo=g_d&tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Gift Subscriptions</a></li> <li><a href="http://help.washingtonpost.com/ics/support/ticketnewwizard.asp?tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Contact Us</a></li> <li><a href="http://help.washingtonpost.com/ics/support/KBSplash.asp?tid=nav_acctmgnt_menu">Help Desk</a></li> </ul> </div> </header> </div> <!--[if IE 8]><div id="main-sections-nav" class="sections-nav ie8"><![endif]--> <!--[if IE 9]><div id="main-sections-nav" class="sections-nav ie9"><![endif]--> <!--[if !IE]><!--> <div id="main-sections-nav" class="sections-nav hide-subscribe-left-nav"> <!--<![endif]--> <div id="main-sections-nav-inner" class="sections-nav unfetched-menu "> <div id="sections-menu-off-canvas-alt"> <ul class="side-nav"> <li id="nav-screenreader-link" class="main-nav nav-screenreader-link"> <a class="main-nav-item screenreader-link" target="_self" href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/?outputType=accessibility&nid=menu_nav_accessibilityforscreenreader">Accessibility for screenreader</a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div id="wp-logo-for-print"> <img class="unprocessed" data-hi-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/washingtonpost_black_32.png" alt="The Washington Post"/> </div> </div> <div id="f0qEqWSNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-ad-leaderboard" moat-id="ad/leaderboard|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="ad/leaderboard" data-pb-fingerprint="0fvmHEvNlqt" id="f0Aa8KxNelfqIq"> <div class="leaderboard ad-hideable"> <wp-ad id="slug_leaderboard" class="pb-ad-container"></wp-ad> <div class="leaderboard-close fa"></div> </div> <div class="mobile-fixed ad-hideable"> <div id="slug_t" data-ad-type="t" class="pb-ad-container-mobile" style="display:none;"> </div> </div> <script>(function(){TWP=window.TWP||{};TWP.Features=TWP.Features||{};TWP.Features.Ad=TWP.Features.Ad||{};TWP.Features.Ad.Leaderboard={};TWP.Features.Ad.Leaderboard.viewability=false;TWP.Features.Ad.Leaderboard.sticky=true;TWP.Features.Ad.Leaderboard.belowSharebar=false})();</script> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-ad-interstitial" moat-id="ad/interstitial|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="ad/interstitial" data-pb-fingerprint="0fWmHEvNlqs" id="fKPoc51NelfqIq"> <div class="zeus-ads-fixed"> <div class="ad-interstitial"></div> </div> <script>(function(){var container=$(".zeus-ads-fixed"),interstitial=document.createElement("WP-AD");interstitial.id="slug_interstitial";$("#pb-root").before(container);if(!$("#slug_interstitial",container).length)$(".ad-interstitial").append(interstitial)})();</script> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-page-ad-blocker" moat-id="page/ad-blocker|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="page/ad-blocker" data-pb-fingerprint="0fBmHEvNlqe" id="f0IdC7YNelfqIq"> </div> <div class="pb-container"> </div></section> <section id="top-content" class="col-lg-12 col-md-12 col-sm-10 col-xs-10 col-xs-offset-1 col-sm-offset-1 col-md-offset-0 col-lg-offset-0 layout"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-article-article-topper" moat-id="article/article-topper|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="article/article-topper" data-pb-fingerprint="0fmmHEvNlq3" id="f0NovVmNelfqIq"> <div class="border-bottom-off border-bottom-"> <div id="article-topper" class="article-topper "> <div class="headline-kicker"><a class='kicker-link' href='http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment'>Energy and Environment</a></div> <div> <div id="topper-headline-wrapper" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-12 col-lg-12"> <h1 data-pb-field="custom.topperDisplayName" itemprop="headline">Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder.</h1> </div> <wp-ad id="slug_tiffany_tile" data-ad-type="tiffany_tile" class="hidden-xs right"></wp-ad> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="pb-container"> </div></section> <section id="main-content" class="col-xl-9 col-lg-8 col-md-8 col-sm-12 col-xs-12 col-xs-offset-0 col-sm-offset-0 col-md-offset-0 col-lg-offset-0 layout"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-article-article-deck" moat-id="article/article-deck|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="article/article-deck" data-pb-fingerprint="0fXmHEvNlqX" id="f0ZJo6gNelfqIq"> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-article-article-body" moat-id="article/article-body|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="article/article-body" data-pb-fingerprint="0fPmHEvNlqi" id="f0Yf2UgNelfqIq"> <div id="article-body" class="article-body content-format-default"> <div class="pb-sig-line hasnt-headshot has-0-headshots hasnt-bio is-not-column"> <span class="pb-byline" itemprop="author" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Person">By <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/people/chris-mooney/"><span itemprop="name">Chris Mooney</span></a></span> <span class="pb-byline-tool-mobile"> <span class="pb-byline" itemprop="author" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Person">By <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/people/chris-mooney/"><span itemprop="name">Chris Mooney</span></a></span> <span class="pb-tool email"><a href="mailto:christopher.mooney@washpost.com?subject=Reader feedback for 'Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder.'"><span class="fa fa-envelope"></span><span class="envelope-label">Email the author</span></a></span> </span> <span class="pb-timestamp" itemprop="datePublished" content="2017-08-30T01:51-500">August 30, 2017</span> <span class="pb-tool email"><a href="mailto:christopher.mooney@washpost.com?subject=Reader feedback for 'Katrina. Sandy. Harvey. The debate over climate and hurricanes is getting louder and louder.'"><span class="fa fa-envelope"></span><span class="envelope-label">Email the author</span></a></span> <span class="tweet-authors"><span class="pb-twitter-follow unprocessed"><a href="https://twitter.com/@chriscmooney" class="twitter-follow-button" data-show-count="false" data-lang="en">Follow @chriscmooney</a></span> </span> <span class="pb-bolt"><i class="fa fa-bolt"></i></span> </div> <article class="paywall" itemprop="articleBody"> <div class="inline-content inline-video"> <div class="posttv-video-embed powa" data-ad-bar="1" data-aspect-ratio="0.5625" data-blurb="1" data-live="0" data-object-id="59a71588e4b090ef295b5c2c" data-org="wapo" data-playthrough="1" data-uuid="9a0a4958-8dbb-11e7-9c53-6a169beb0953" data-youtube-id="s_VOigoLwcs"> <script async="" src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/player/prod/PoWaLoaderWapo.js?_=20180215"></script> </div> <div class="inline-video-caption"> <span class="pb-caption">Capital Weather Gang's Angela Fritz answers six key questions about Harvey and its ongoing impact on the Texas coast and Southwestern Louisiana. (Claritza Jimenez,Angela Fritz/The Washington Post)</span> </div> </div> <div class="flex-embed-dummy-script"><script charset="utf-8"></script></div> <p>Almost exactly 12 years ago, when Hurricane Katrina put much of New Orleans under water, it touched off a massive dispute among scientists about the relationship between hurricanes and global warming.</p> <p>Now, it’s happening again. Harvey, with its unprecedented rains, has spawned an urgent debate over whether this is what a changing climate looks like.</p> <p>Yet while the argument following Katrina lacked any satisfying resolution, today we may be getting closer to answering questions about how a changing climate worsens hurricanes.</p> <p>At least two things have changed in the intervening years. One is the availability of new analytical approaches and more powerful supercomputers.</p> <p>“The methodological frameworks were very much in their infancy at the time of Katrina in 2005,” said Noah Diffenbaugh, a Stanford climate researcher who performs climate change “attribution” studies, seeking to determine how the probability of various weather events has changed as a result of the warming of the climate.</p> <p>There’s another change. Today, despite <a href="http://www.reuters.com/article/us-storm-harvey-climatechange-idUSKCN1B92V0">recent charges</a> from Environmental Protection Agency spokeswoman Liz Bowman that they are “engaging in attempts to politicize an ongoing tragedy,” many researchers are more willing to simply say that Harvey’s record rains were worse because of our hotter, wetter climate.</p> <p>“Climate change worsened the impact of Hurricane Harvey,” stated Penn State climate scientist Michael Mann bluntly, in a <a href="https://www.facebook.com/MichaelMannScientist/posts/1515449771844553">much-quoted Facebook post </a>about the storm.</p> <p><strong>The climate-hurricane debate of yesteryear</strong></p> <p>Shortly before and after Katrina, several researchers published studies suggesting that more intense hurricanes were linked to rising ocean temperatures. That made sense: Hurricanes draw heat energy from the oceans and turn it into powerful winds and rain.</p> <p>But there was a big problem: Data. You don’t know how strong a hurricane is unless you can measure it, and hurricane measurement techniques are highly inconsistent around the globe and were less reliable in the past than they are today. Accordingly, other scientists questioned the ability to detect strong hurricane trends.</p> <p>The tone at the time was quite cautious. Even the scientists arguing for a climate connection tended to underscore that they weren’t talking about <em>Katrina </em>but, rather, about hurricanes in general.</p> <p>Yet the context was hard to miss, as Katrina proved a devastating political event for President George W. Bush, whose administration had made a habit of sowing doubts about climate change.</p> <div class="inline-content inline-photo inline-photo-normal"> <a name="c3d484ee67"></a> <img class="unprocessed placeholder" data-hi-res-src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_908w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2013/07/29/Interactivity/Images/6-976572581375138742.jpg&amp;w=1484" data-low-res-src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_908w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2013/07/29/Interactivity/Images/6-976572581375138742.jpg&amp;w=480" data-raw-src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_908w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2013/07/29/Interactivity/Images/6-976572581375138742.jpg" src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_908w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2013/07/29/Interactivity/Images/6-976572581375138742.jpg&amp;w=60"/><br/> <span class="pb-caption">Water spills over a levee along the Inner Harbor Navigational Canal in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina Aug. 30, 2005, in New Orleans.  (Pool/AFP/Getty Images)</span> </div> <p>The researchers also emphasized repeatedly that global warming doesn’t cause individual storm events. They’re products of a swarm of atmospheric and oceanic conditions — and what perhaps matters most is the broader pattern of winds that steer a given storm toward its landfall in a particular location.</p> <p>And nobody — at least, at the time — seemed to be saying that these steering winds were being altered by climate change.</p> <p><strong>Superstorm Sandy shifts the narrative</strong></p> <p>The tone began to change when another major U.S. city was flooded by another suspicious storm.</p> <p>In the case of Superstorm Sandy in 2012, the storm’s <a href="http://www.ldeo.columbia.edu/~sobel/Papers/hall_sobel_grl_submitted.pdf">particular path</a> — a beeline toward New Jersey, rather than out to sea — was abnormal. Atlantic hurricanes often <a href="https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/news/historical-hurricanes/">“recurve” and flow away from the United States</a> as they travel farther northward.</p> <p>Sandy <a href="http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/data/tcr/AL182012_Sandy.pdf">did the opposite</a>.</p> <p>In <a href="http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/grl.50395/full">one analysis</a>, NASA’s Timothy Hall and Columbia University’s Adam Sobel found that Sandy’s sharp turn toward New Jersey is expected to happen only once every 714 years, based on the history of Atlantic storms.</p> <p>The result “implies either that the New York-New Jersey area simply experienced a very rare event (with climate change playing no significant role), or that a climate-change influence increased the probability of its occurrence,” they wrote in a 2013 study on Sandy’s angle of approach.</p> <div class="inline-content inline-photo inline-photo-normal"> <a name="e7f01abe7f"></a> <img class="unprocessed placeholder" data-hi-res-src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_960w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2015/10/31/Editorial-Opinion/Images/18624022_H1117443-1656.JPG&amp;w=1484" data-low-res-src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_960w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2015/10/31/Editorial-Opinion/Images/18624022_H1117443-1656.JPG&amp;w=480" data-raw-src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_960w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2015/10/31/Editorial-Opinion/Images/18624022_H1117443-1656.JPG" src="https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_960w/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2015/10/31/Editorial-Opinion/Images/18624022_H1117443-1656.JPG&amp;w=60"/><br/> <span class="pb-caption">Gasoline surrounds vehicles submerged in water in the financial district of New York on Oct. 30, 2012, in the wake of Sandy. (Victor J. Blue/Bloomberg News)</span> </div> <p>Some researchers, like Jennifer Francis of Rutgers University, suggested a potential climate role. Francis argued that the warming of the Arctic, at a much faster pace than the mid-latitudes, is slowing the jet stream and prompting extreme weather events when there’s weak atmospheric flow. She <a href="https://tos.org/oceanography/assets/docs/26-1_greene.pdf">specifically cited</a> Sandy’s strange behavior.</p> <p><strong>“</strong>We were just coming off of a record-smashing low sea-ice year in 2012,” Francis <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/hurricane-sandy-spawns-storm-of-climate-research/">told Climate Central in 2014</a>. “The block that played such a key role in Sandy’s ‘weirdness’ seemed like an amazing coincidence.”</p> <p>But other researchers strongly disputed Francis’s jet stream idea — which continues to divide scientists even today.</p> <p>Meanwhile, watching the floodwaters swamp New York, some observers began to make a relatively simple but resonant observation. Sea levels, they noted, are higher today than they were when similar storms affected New York in the past — and nobody really disputes that the warming of the planet is driving sea level rise.</p> <p>That led to the inference that at least some of what Sandy threw at New York was in a sense, extra. And maybe that water made a difference.</p> <p>As MIT’s Kerry Emanuel, who published one of the key studies in the wake of Katrina, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/25/what-you-can-and-cant-say-about-climate-change-and-hurricane-harvey/">put it to The Post last week</a>: “New York, when Sandy hit, the sea level was already about a foot higher than it was 100 years earlier. So if Sandy had hit in 1912, it probably would not have flooded Lower Manhattan.”</p> <p>Indeed, <a href="http://www.pnas.org/content/113/43/12071.full">subsequent research</a> found that the chances of a Sandy-style flood event are higher today and will only grow further as seas continue to rise.</p> <p><strong>Changing the burden of proof</strong></p> <p>Meanwhile, some scientists were questioning what they viewed as a default assumption that one must prove that a given storm is influenced by climate change — seeking to flip the question and, instead, suggest that all storms today are so influenced.</p> <p>Kevin Trenberth of the National Center for Atmospheric Research, has argued that storm thermodynamics — the heat and moisture that serve as fuel — are strongly climate-dependent. In particular, Trenberth argues that hurricanes and other storms will rain more today because the warmer atmosphere carries more moisture.</p> <p>“The environment in which all weather events occur is not what it used to be,” <a href="http://nature.com/articles/doi:10.1038/nclimate2657">wrote</a> Trenberth and his colleagues John Fasullo and Theodore Shepherd in 2015. “All storms, without exception, are different.”</p> <p>All these threads come together with Harvey. We have a storm that rapidly intensified over warm oceans and had an exceedingly odd track that led it to move very slowly, lingering in place amid a lack of strong atmospheric steering currents and dumping record rainfall.</p> <p>Some researchers today are taking Trenberth’s broad approach and simply highlighting that a warmer atmosphere holds more water vapor and, thus, suggesting that climate change worsened Harvey’s rains.</p> <p>“Harvey was not caused by climate change, yet its impacts — the storm surge, and especially the extreme rainfall — very likely worsened due to human-caused global warming,” said Stefan Rahmstorf, a researcher with the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, in a statement.</p> <p>Rahmstorf said in a follow up email that this is just basic physics, citing the <a href="http://glossary.ametsoc.org/wiki/Clausius-clapeyron_equation">Clausius-Clapeyron equation</a>, which shows that the atmosphere holds more water vapor when it is warmer, setting the stage for more rainfall.</p> <p>“It is about 7% more water vapor per degree C of warming,” he said. “The [equation] tends to be a good approximation for extreme rainfall events because they tend to occur with moisture-saturated air masses.”</p> <p><strong>Enter the attributionists</strong></p> <p>But it would be considerably more powerful to say that because of the warming of the planet, a storm like Harvey was statistically more likely to occur — and give the odds. And scientists just might be on the cusp of doing that.</p> <p>Such analysis requires an “attribution study,” which often uses myriad runs of high-powered computer models to determine the odds of an event occurring with, and without, human-caused changes to the atmosphere. Attribution science has been evolving alongside the hurricane debate: One of the first such studies, <a href="http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v432/n7017/abs/nature03089.html">published in 2004</a>, examined an extreme and deadly 2003 European heat wave.</p> <p>Such studies may allow researchers to  say that some aspect of Harvey, such as its path or its rainfall, was more likely to occur in the current climate than in an unaltered one.</p> <p>“I would actually be really surprised if you don’t start seeing those kind of studies coming out within six to 10 weeks. My guess is it will be weeks, not months to years,” said David Titley, a meteorologist at Penn State University who chaired a National Academy of Sciences report on the attribution studies in question.</p> <p>Yet complex atmospheric and ocean phenomena such as hurricanes remain a difficulty in such studies, in part because of the computing power required. Heat waves are far easier to attribute to a warming climate in a statistical sense.</p> <p>“Attribution is still a young science, and there have been big disagreements in the field,” Columbia’s Sobel said. “This is still the bleeding edge of what we can do.”</p> <p>Still, Stanford’s Diffenbaugh agreed that before long — if they haven’t begun already — scientists will be looking very closely at the Harvey event, based on its thermodynamics (storm intensity and rainfall) and its “dynamics,” or the broader atmospheric flow factors that led the storm to stall.</p> <p>Titley thinks climate analyses will try to suss out the likelihood of Harvey’s track, just as occurred with Sandy. “The fact that nothing in the atmosphere was there to kick it out or shear it apart or do anything with it, really is this kind of worst-case scenario here,” he said. “So the question going forward is: Are these situations going to be more likely or did we just get unlucky?”</p> <p>But not all scientists agree that attribution studies are the way to go.</p> <p>“I think they provide at best a limited view of the climate connections,” said Penn State’s Mann by email. “Simple physics (effect of [sea-level rise] on storm surge) and simple thermodynamics (i.e. Clausius-Clapeyron) are valid whether or not we can trust the models to get the specifics dynamical linkages between climate change and extreme weather events right (and I’m deeply skeptical the models are up to this task at present).”</p> <p>In the meantime, watching the evolution of the debate over hurricanes and climate change, several things are clear. First, major storm events drive science. They force researchers to ask questions, and the ensuing inquiry improves our answers.</p> <p>The second, meanwhile, is that we have had devastating flooding of a major city from a hurricane event in each of the last three presidencies, even as the climate hurricane debate has grown steadily more insistent. At this point, we surely have the right to wonder, just as scientists themselves are already doing, whether the burden of proof has shifted.</p></article> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> <div id="fHfQUf1NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="chain-wrapper standard-chain in-chain border-bottom-hairline border-bottom-100-pct pb-layout-item pb-chain pb-c-standard-chain full" data-chain-name="no-name" id="cHQge52NelfqIq"> <div class="chain-content no-skin clear"> <div id="f038U0vNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="fDo8482NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div id="fIHDx42NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="fl0TkR1NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="fCTYF11NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="fL6LwZ1NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-tools-feature-loader" moat-id="tools/feature-loader|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="comments-loader" data-feature-id="tools/feature-loader" data-pb-fingerprint="0fF13aLvyqz" id="fpGhW81NelfqIq"> <div data-conditionsurl="/resources/conditions/comments.json" data-contenturi="/pb/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/" class="feature-loader-config" style="display: none"></div> </div> <div id="f0q7wbZNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="pb-container"> </div></section> <section id="right-rail" class="col-xl-3 col-lg-4 col-md-4 col-sm-10 col-xs-10 col-xs-offset-1 col-sm-offset-1 col-md-offset-0 layout"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-ad-flex" moat-id="ad/flex|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="ad/flex" data-pb-fingerprint="0fhmHEvNlqi" id="f4pc9f1NelfqIq"> <wp-ad id="slug_flex_ss_bb_hp" class="pb-ad-container border-bottom-airy border-bottom-" data-ad-type="flex_ss_bb_hp"></wp-ad> <script>(function(){TWP=window.TWP||{};TWP.Features=TWP.Features||{};TWP.Features.Ad=TWP.Features.Ad||{};TWP.Features.Ad.flexAd={};TWP.Features.Ad.flexAd.sticky=true})();</script> </div> <div id="f0e69gYNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-ad-flex-2" moat-id="ad/flex-2|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="ad/flex-2" data-pb-fingerprint="0fomHEvNlqo" id="fPUjKe2NelfqIq"> <wp-ad id="slug_flex_ss_bb_hp_2" class="pb-ad-container border-bottom-airy border-bottom-" data-ad-type-placeholder="flex_ss_bb_hp|2" data-ad-delivery="vi"></wp-ad> </div> <div class="chain-wrapper standard-chain in-chain border-bottom-hairline border-bottom-100-pct extra-padding-off extra-padding-0 extra-padding-no-threshold pb-layout-item pb-chain pb-c-standard-chain full" data-chain-name="no-name" id="c00sVnzNelfqIq"> <div class="chain-content no-skin clear"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-homepage-story" moat-id="homepage/story|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="hta-teaser" data-feature-id="homepage/story" data-pb-fingerprint="0fhIlKqerqt-c-c" id="fgfAjt1NelfqIq"> <div class="border-top-negative border-top-100-pct border-bottom-tight border-bottom-100-pct"> <div class="no-skin flex-item flex-stack normal-air text-align-left equalize-height-target"> <div class="label-wrapper text-align-inherit "> <div class=" label label-kicker label-primary" data-pb-field="custom.label" data-pb-placeholder="Label">How to Adult</div> </div> <div class="blurb normal normal-style " data-pb-field="summary" data-pb-placeholder="Write blurb here." data-pb-url-field="canonical_url">A new video series from The Washington Post</div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-homepage-story" moat-id="homepage/story|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="hta-buy-a-car" data-feature-id="homepage/story" data-pb-fingerprint="0fBnfeWQvq0-c-c" id="f06JZuPNelfqIq"> <div class="border-top-off border-top-100-pct border-bottom-hairline border-bottom-100-pct"> <div class="no-skin flex-item flex-stack normal-air text-align-left equalize-height-target"> <div class="art art-high art-small enforce-max art-full-width text-align-left no-extra-rule"> <div class="photo-wrapper"><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/entertainment/how-to-adult-how-to-buy-a-car/2017/09/26/5d913dd0-995d-11e7-af6a-6555caaeb8dc_video.html"><img src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/pbox.php?url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/spacer.gif&amp;op=resize&amp;w=16&amp;h=9&amp;filter=nearest&amp;fmt=png&amp;t=20170517a" data-hi-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=http://s3.amazonaws.com/posttv-thumbnails-prod/09-27-2017/t_1506529047477_name_howtocar.jpg&amp;w=1248&amp;h=701&amp;t=20170517a" data-low-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=http://s3.amazonaws.com/posttv-thumbnails-prod/09-27-2017/t_1506529047477_name_howtocar.jpg&amp;w=480&amp;h=270&amp;t=20170517a" data-threshold="480" width="480" height="270" class=" _16-to-9 unprocessed placeholder"></a></div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div class="headline x-small highlight-style text-align-inherit "><a class="" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/entertainment/how-to-adult-how-to-buy-a-car/2017/09/26/5d913dd0-995d-11e7-af6a-6555caaeb8dc_video.html" data-pb-field="web_headline" data-pb-url-field="canonical_url" data-pb-placeholder="Write headline here">How to buy a car</a></div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-homepage-story" moat-id="homepage/story|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="hta-401k" data-feature-id="homepage/story" data-pb-fingerprint="0fe7rbZ7eqD-c-c" id="f0pNeCpNelfqIq"> <div class="border-top-off border-top-100-pct border-bottom-hairline border-bottom-100-pct"> <div class="no-skin flex-item flex-stack normal-air text-align-left equalize-height-target"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-xs-4 art-left flex-stack-art flex-stack"> <div class="art art-left art-small enforce-max art-left text-align-left "> <div class="photo-wrapper"><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/entertainment/how-to-adult-how-to-start-a-401k/2017/09/26/a15ada36-a2d5-11e7-b573-8ec86cdfe1ed_video.html"><img src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/pbox.php?url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/spacer.gif&amp;op=resize&amp;w=3&amp;h=2&amp;filter=nearest&amp;fmt=png&amp;t=20170517a" data-hi-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=http://s3.amazonaws.com/posttv-thumbnails-prod/09-27-2017/t_1506528985330_name_401K.jpg&amp;w=480&amp;h=320&amp;t=20170517a" data-low-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=http://s3.amazonaws.com/posttv-thumbnails-prod/09-27-2017/t_1506528985330_name_401K.jpg&amp;w=112&amp;h=75&amp;t=20170517a" data-threshold="112" width="112" height="75" class=" _3-to-2 unprocessed placeholder"></a></div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> <div class="flex-stack normal-air col-xs-8 flex-stack-text"> <div class="headline xx-small highlight-style text-align-inherit "><a class="" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/entertainment/how-to-adult-how-to-start-a-401k/2017/09/26/a15ada36-a2d5-11e7-b573-8ec86cdfe1ed_video.html" data-pb-field="web_headline" data-pb-url-field="canonical_url" data-pb-placeholder="Write headline here">How to start a 401(k)</a></div> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-homepage-story" moat-id="homepage/story|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="hta-dinner-party" data-feature-id="homepage/story" data-pb-fingerprint="0fRWnQy1tq6-c-c" id="f0BJCZZNelfqIq"> <div class="border-top-off border-top-100-pct border-bottom-hairline border-bottom-100-pct"> <div class="no-skin flex-item flex-stack normal-air text-align-left equalize-height-target"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-xs-4 art-left flex-stack-art flex-stack"> <div class="art art-left art-small enforce-max art-left text-align-left "> <div class="photo-wrapper"><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/entertainment/how-to-adult-how-to-throw-a-dinner-party/2017/10/03/48d75df8-a843-11e7-9a98-07140d2eed02_video.html"><img src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/pbox.php?url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/resources/img/spacer.gif&amp;op=resize&amp;w=3&amp;h=2&amp;filter=nearest&amp;fmt=png&amp;t=20170517a" data-hi-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_480x320/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2017/10/03/Style/Videos/Images/t_1507038688573_name_20171002_hta_dinner_final00.jpg?t=20170517a" data-low-res-src="https://www.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_112x75/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2017/10/03/Style/Videos/Images/t_1507038688573_name_20171002_hta_dinner_final00.jpg?t=20170517a" data-threshold="112" width="112" height="75" class=" _3-to-2 unprocessed placeholder"></a></div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> <div class="flex-stack normal-air col-xs-8 flex-stack-text"> <div class="headline xx-small highlight-style text-align-inherit "><a class="" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/entertainment/how-to-adult-how-to-throw-a-dinner-party/2017/10/03/48d75df8-a843-11e7-9a98-07140d2eed02_video.html" data-pb-field="web_headline" data-pb-url-field="canonical_url" data-pb-placeholder="Write headline here">How to throw a dinner party</a></div> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div id="fQKoVJ1NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="f0BVqyoNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="f0AxTCMNelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="fJRel42NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-ad-flex-3" moat-id="ad/flex-3|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="ad/flex-3" data-pb-fingerprint="0fXmHEvNlqd" id="f0mKhdYNelfqIq"> <wp-ad id="slug_flex_ss_bb_hp_3" class="pb-ad-container border-bottom-airy border-bottom-"data-ad-type-placeholder="flex_ss_bb_hp|3" data-ad-delivery="vi"></wp-ad> <script>(function(){TWP=window.TWP||{};TWP.Features=TWP.Features||{};TWP.Features.Ad=TWP.Features.Ad||{};TWP.Features.Ad.flexAd3={};TWP.Features.Ad.flexAd3.sticky=true})();</script> </div> <div id="f0Oxkm9NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-posttv-sticky-player-powa" moat-id="posttv/sticky-player-powa|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="posttv/sticky-player-powa" data-pb-fingerprint="0f0iSx3RnqS" id="fVyTEl1NelfqIq"><div class="posttv-sticky-player-video pb-font-smoothing wpv-hidden"> <div class="posttv-sticky-player-exit"><span class="franklin-bold">Close</span><i class="fa fa-times"></i></div> <div class="posttv-sticky-player-wrapper" id="posttv-sticky-player-wrapper"></div> <div class="posttv-sticky-player-text wpv-hidden"> <div class="label label-normal">Now Playing</div> <div class="posttv-sticky-player-caption pb-caption"></div> </div> </div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div class="pb-container"> </div></section> <section id="bottom-content" class="col-xs-12 layout"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-ad-leaderboard-2" moat-id="ad/leaderboard-2|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="ad/leaderboard-2" data-pb-fingerprint="0fFmHEvNlqM" id="fekzJU1NelfqIq"> </div> <div class="pb-container"> </div></section> <section id="bottom-furniture" class="col-xs-12 layout"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-tools-feature-loader" moat-id="tools/feature-loader|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="drawbridge-loader" data-feature-id="tools/feature-loader" data-pb-fingerprint="0fjmHEvNlqg" id="fQwL311NelfqIq"> <script type="application/json" class="feature-loader-config">
          {
  "modal-adblock_v2-controlvar": {
    "async": true,
    "condition": {
      "func": "abtest",
      "params": ["modal-adblock_v2", "controlvar"]
    },
    "action": {
      "func": "loadFeature",
      "params": [
        {
          "featureConfigID": "drawbridge/base"
        },
        {
          "customFields": {
            "type": "modal",
            "conversionType": "adblocker",
            "theme": "blueLeft",
            "header": "We noticed you’re blocking ads.",
            "body": "",
            "subHeader": "Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on.",
            "buttonOneTxt": "Unblock ads",
            "buttonOneSubText": "",
            "buttonOneURL": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/steps-for-disabling-adblocker/2016/09/14/a8c3d4d2-7aac-11e6-bd86-b7bbd53d2b5d_story.html",
            "buttonTwoTxt":"Subscribe",
            "buttonTwoURL" : "https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/acquisition/?promo=o12_t_zwy0917_1&view=1&ttexclude=1",
            "buttonTwoStyle": "button",
            "newsletterName": "adblocker",
            "template": "drawbridge-no-sub",
            "initiative": "adblocker",
            "promoId": "none",
            "image": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/drawbridge-popup-lg.png",
            "imageSmall": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/TWP_logo@2x.png"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "modal-adblock_v2-var1": {
    "async": true,
    "condition": {
      "func": "abtest",
      "params": ["modal-adblock_v2", "var1"]
    },
    "action": {
      "func": "loadFeature",
      "params": [
        {
          "featureConfigID": "drawbridge/base"
        },
        {
          "customFields": {
            "type": "modal",
            "conversionType": "adblocker",
            "theme": "blueLeft",
            "header": "We noticed you’re blocking ads.",
            "body": "",
            "subHeader": "Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on.",
            "buttonOneTxt": "Subscribe now",
            "buttonOneSubText": "Only $1 for the first 4 weeks",
            "buttonOneURL": "https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/acquisition/?promo=o12_t_zwy0917_2&view=1&ttexclude=1",
            "buttonTwoTxt":"Unblock ads",
            "buttonTwoURL" : "https://www.washingtonpost.com/steps-for-disabling-adblocker/2016/09/14/a8c3d4d2-7aac-11e6-bd86-b7bbd53d2b5d_story.html",
            "buttonTwoStyle": "button",
            "newsletterName": "adblocker",
            "template": "drawbridge-no-sub",
            "initiative": "adblocker",
            "promoId": "none",
            "image": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/drawbridge-popup-lg.png",
            "imageSmall": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/TWP_logo@2x.png"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "modal-adblock_v2-var2": {
    "async": true,
    "condition": {
      "func": "abtest",
      "params": ["modal-adblock_v2", "var2"]
    },
    "action": {
      "func": "loadFeature",
      "params": [
        {
          "featureConfigID": "drawbridge/base"
        },
        {
          "customFields": {
            "type": "modal",
            "conversionType": "adblocker",
            "theme": "blueLeft",
            "header": "We noticed you’re blocking ads.",
            "body": "",
            "subHeader": "Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on.",
            "buttonOneTxt": "Subscribe now",
            "buttonOneSubText": "Only $1 for the first 4 weeks",
            "buttonOneURL": "https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/acquisition/?promo=o12_t_zwy0917_3&view=1&ttexclude=1",
            "buttonTwoTxt":"Unblock ads",
            "buttonTwoURL" : "https://www.washingtonpost.com/steps-for-disabling-adblocker/2016/09/14/a8c3d4d2-7aac-11e6-bd86-b7bbd53d2b5d_story.html",
            "buttonTwoStyle": "underlined",
            "newsletterName": "adblocker",
            "template": "drawbridge-no-sub",
            "initiative": "adblocker",
            "promoId": "none",
            "image": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/drawbridge-popup-lg.png",
            "imageSmall": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/TWP_logo@2x.png"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "modal-adblock_v2-var3": {
    "async": true,
    "condition": {
      "func": "abtest",
      "params": ["modal-adblock_v2", "var3"]
    },
    "action": {
      "func": "loadFeature",
      "params": [
        {
          "featureConfigID": "drawbridge/base"
        },
        {
          "customFields": {
            "type": "modal",
            "conversionType": "adblocker",
            "theme": "blueLeft",
            "header": "We noticed you’re blocking ads.",
            "body": "",
            "subHeader": "Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on.",
            "buttonOneTxt": "See subscription plans",
            "buttonOneSubText": "",
            "buttonOneURL": "https://subscribe.washingtonpost.com/acquisition/?promo=o12_t_zwy0917_4&view=1&ttexclude=1",
            "buttonTwoTxt":"Learn how to unblock ads",
            "buttonTwoURL" : "https://www.washingtonpost.com/steps-for-disabling-adblocker/2016/09/14/a8c3d4d2-7aac-11e6-bd86-b7bbd53d2b5d_story.html",
            "buttonTwoStyle": "underlined",
            "newsletterName": "adblocker",
            "template": "drawbridge-no-sub",
            "initiative": "adblocker",
            "promoId": "none",
            "image": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/drawbridge-popup-lg.png",
            "imageSmall": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/resources/img/drawbridge/TWP_logo@2x.png"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  }
}
        </script> </div> <div id="fTATWj2NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false full pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-page-clavis" moat-id="page/clavis|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="page/clavis" data-pb-fingerprint="0f1mHEvNlqs" id="f0JQJ71NelfqIq"> <script>try{if(wp_meta_data){if(!wp_meta_data.clavis)wp_meta_data.clavis={};(function(){var clavisAuxs=[];var clavisAuxNames=[];var clavisKeywords=[];var clavisTopics=[];var clavisTopicsDFP=[];clavisAuxs.push("wkq");clavisAuxNames.push("Science,%20Health%20\x26%20Technology");clavisAuxs.push("v57");clavisAuxNames.push("Weather");clavisAuxs.push("wmp");clavisAuxNames.push("Disaster-natural");clavisAuxs.push("q12");clavisAuxNames.push("March%20Madness");clavisAuxs.push("eiz");clavisAuxNames.push("MS%20kws");
clavisAuxs.push("WKH");clavisAuxNames.push("Facebook kw");clavisAuxs.push("XHB");clavisAuxNames.push("cit kws");clavisAuxs.push("4y6");clavisAuxNames.push("Cvy%20kws");clavisAuxs.push("xyt");clavisAuxNames.push("food%20safety%20neg");clavisAuxs.push("00T");clavisAuxNames.push("NBA Basketball");clavisAuxs.push("gno");clavisAuxNames.push("Space");clavisAuxs.push("l7l");clavisAuxNames.push("Ahld");clavisAuxs.push("fdv");clavisAuxNames.push("Lowes");clavisAuxs.push("GQP");clavisAuxNames.push("intel kw");
clavisAuxs.push("wtg");clavisAuxNames.push("Exxn%20neg%20v2");clavisAuxs.push("80A");clavisAuxNames.push("Data Center Buyer");clavisAuxs.push("zhn");clavisAuxNames.push("Emissions");clavisAuxs.push("WC9");clavisAuxNames.push("Election%202016");clavisAuxs.push("5ex");clavisAuxNames.push("ConocoPhillips(test)");clavisAuxs.push("PKT");clavisAuxNames.push("bp kws");clavisAuxs.push("n95");clavisAuxNames.push("BofA%20Dashboard%20Auxiliary");clavisAuxs.push("7qn");clavisAuxNames.push("Citi%20Segment%20-%20Future%20Focused");
clavisAuxs.push("02c");clavisAuxNames.push("emails%20-%20pos");clavisAuxs.push("DXM");clavisAuxNames.push("Solar Eclipse Content");clavisAuxs.push("81f");clavisAuxNames.push("smsg%20kws");clavisAuxs.push("IAM");clavisAuxNames.push("aig kws");clavisAuxs.push("QT4");clavisAuxNames.push("WstnKw");clavisAuxs.push("0KS");clavisAuxNames.push("Sub%3A%20Neutral");clavisAuxs.push("7aq");clavisAuxNames.push("Sensitive%202");clavisAuxs.push("97K");clavisAuxNames.push("Travel%20TG");clavisAuxs.push("0PV");clavisAuxNames.push("Solar Eclipse");
clavisAuxs.push("5k4");clavisAuxNames.push("China_HongKong%20Exclusion%2012-12-14");clavisAuxs.push("crl");clavisAuxNames.push("Horse%20Enthusiasts%204.13.15");clavisAuxs.push("IAJ");clavisAuxNames.push("New Auxiliary 460");clavisAuxs.push("11S");clavisAuxNames.push("citi kws");clavisAuxs.push("0GA");clavisAuxNames.push("BofA Audience 101017");clavisAuxs.push("zwn");clavisAuxNames.push("Murdoch%20neg");clavisAuxs.push("d77");clavisAuxNames.push("Environment%20and%20Nature");clavisAuxs.push("m42");
clavisAuxNames.push("Boa-kws");clavisAuxs.push("8z8");clavisAuxNames.push("Sensitive1");clavisAuxs.push("7rl");clavisAuxNames.push("Icahn%20neg");clavisAuxs.push("BUM");clavisAuxNames.push("api kws");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane");clavisKeywords.push("Sandy");clavisKeywords.push("storm");clavisKeywords.push("climate");clavisKeywords.push("Harvey");clavisKeywords.push("warming");clavisKeywords.push("Katrina");clavisKeywords.push("study");clavisKeywords.push("scientist");clavisKeywords.push("Trenberth");
clavisKeywords.push("researcher");clavisKeywords.push("attribution");clavisKeywords.push("rainfall");clavisKeywords.push("sandy");clavisKeywords.push("Francis");clavisKeywords.push("moisture");clavisKeywords.push("atmosphere");clavisKeywords.push("today");clavisKeywords.push("thermodynamics");clavisKeywords.push("harvey");clavisKeywords.push("change");clavisKeywords.push("ocean");clavisKeywords.push("new york");clavisKeywords.push("New");clavisKeywords.push("katrina");clavisKeywords.push("model");
clavisKeywords.push("rain");clavisKeywords.push("event");clavisKeywords.push("sea");clavisKeywords.push("wind");clavisKeywords.push("debate");clavisKeywords.push("climate change");clavisKeywords.push("physics");clavisKeywords.push("equation");clavisKeywords.push("probability");clavisKeywords.push("York");clavisKeywords.push("Rahmstorf");clavisKeywords.push("Titley");clavisKeywords.push("question");clavisKeywords.push("supercomputer");clavisKeywords.push("water");clavisKeywords.push("approach");clavisKeywords.push("yesteryear");
clavisKeywords.push("recurve");clavisKeywords.push("beeline");clavisKeywords.push("science");clavisKeywords.push("mid-latitudes");clavisKeywords.push("planet");clavisKeywords.push("weirdness");clavisKeywords.push("attributionist");clavisKeywords.push("proof");clavisKeywords.push("clausius-clapeyron");clavisKeywords.push("burden");clavisKeywords.push("sense");clavisKeywords.push("tone");clavisKeywords.push("analysis");clavisKeywords.push("infancy");clavisKeywords.push("odds");clavisKeywords.push("nobody");
clavisKeywords.push("Hurricanes");clavisKeywords.push("weather event");clavisKeywords.push("approximation");clavisKeywords.push("shear");clavisKeywords.push("Stanford");clavisKeywords.push("heatwave");clavisKeywords.push("wake");clavisKeywords.push("linkage");clavisKeywords.push("dispute");clavisKeywords.push("path");clavisKeywords.push("francis");clavisKeywords.push("Hurricane");clavisKeywords.push("trenberth");clavisKeywords.push("track");clavisKeywords.push("water vapor");clavisKeywords.push("floodwater");
clavisKeywords.push("landfall");clavisKeywords.push("swarm");clavisKeywords.push("inference");clavisKeywords.push("MIT");clavisKeywords.push("Central");clavisKeywords.push("availability");clavisKeywords.push("cusp");clavisKeywords.push("Columbia");clavisKeywords.push("Sciences");clavisKeywords.push("email");clavisKeywords.push("meteorologist");clavisKeywords.push("Arctic");clavisKeywords.push("framework");clavisKeywords.push("heat");clavisKeywords.push("resolution");clavisKeywords.push("impact");
clavisKeywords.push("Jersey");clavisKeywords.push("occurrence");clavisKeywords.push("role");clavisKeywords.push("flow");clavisKeywords.push("thread");clavisKeywords.push("dynamics");clavisKeywords.push("vapor");clavisKeywords.push("coincidence");clavisKeywords.push("relationship");clavisKeywords.push("guess");clavisKeywords.push("angle");clavisKeywords.push("NASA");clavisKeywords.push("habit");clavisKeywords.push("observation");clavisKeywords.push("flooding");clavisKeywords.push("specifics");clavisKeywords.push("evolution");
clavisKeywords.push("disagreement");clavisKeywords.push("noah diffenbaugh");clavisKeywords.push("Noah Diffenbaugh");clavisKeywords.push("Diffenbaugh");clavisKeywords.push("meantime");clavisKeywords.push("superstorm sandy");clavisKeywords.push("Superstorm");clavisKeywords.push("climate connection");clavisKeywords.push("new jersey");clavisKeywords.push("storm event");clavisKeywords.push("likelihood");clavisKeywords.push("University");clavisKeywords.push("Manhattan");clavisKeywords.push("observer");
clavisKeywords.push("Adam Sobel");clavisKeywords.push("adam sobel");clavisKeywords.push("Sobel");clavisKeywords.push("week");clavisKeywords.push("kind");clavisKeywords.push("storm surge");clavisKeywords.push("narrative");clavisKeywords.push("State");clavisKeywords.push("attribution study");clavisKeywords.push("New York");clavisKeywords.push("Orleans");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane katrina");clavisKeywords.push("new orleans");clavisKeywords.push("pattern");clavisKeywords.push("difficulty");clavisKeywords.push("context");
clavisKeywords.push("rise");clavisKeywords.push("tragedy");clavisKeywords.push("fuel");clavisKeywords.push("argument");clavisKeywords.push("weather");clavisKeywords.push("exception");clavisKeywords.push("inquiry");clavisKeywords.push("aspect");clavisKeywords.push("Superstorm Sandy");clavisKeywords.push("task");clavisKeywords.push("plenty");clavisKeywords.push("presidency");clavisKeywords.push("influence");clavisKeywords.push("administration");clavisKeywords.push("Mann");clavisKeywords.push("pace");
clavisKeywords.push("edge");clavisKeywords.push("post");clavisKeywords.push("block");clavisKeywords.push("turn");clavisKeywords.push("behavior");clavisKeywords.push("environment");clavisKeywords.push("attempt");clavisKeywords.push("thing");clavisKeywords.push("location");clavisKeywords.push("product");clavisKeywords.push("research");clavisKeywords.push("Hurricane Katrina");clavisKeywords.push("Adam");clavisKeywords.push("past");clavisKeywords.push("Noah");clavisKeywords.push("sea level");clavisKeywords.push("era");
clavisKeywords.push("ability");clavisKeywords.push("lack");clavisKeywords.push("answer");clavisKeywords.push("difference");clavisKeywords.push("stage");clavisKeywords.push("Michael");clavisKeywords.push("level");clavisKeywords.push("field");clavisKeywords.push("charge");clavisKeywords.push("Pennsylvania");clavisKeywords.push("foot");clavisKeywords.push("effect");clavisKeywords.push("run");clavisKeywords.push("condition");clavisKeywords.push("National");clavisKeywords.push("right");clavisKeywords.push("view");
clavisKeywords.push("datum");clavisKeywords.push("Research");clavisKeywords.push("situation");clavisKeywords.push("stanford climate researcher");clavisKeywords.push("Stanford climate researcher");clavisKeywords.push("epa spokeswoman liz bowman");clavisKeywords.push("Liz");clavisKeywords.push("record rain");clavisKeywords.push("EPA spokeswoman Liz Bowman");clavisKeywords.push("Atlantic");clavisKeywords.push("city");clavisKeywords.push("anything");clavisKeywords.push("Hurricane Harvey");clavisKeywords.push("Penn State climate scientist Michael Mann");
clavisKeywords.push("penn state climate scientist michael mann");clavisKeywords.push("facebook post");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane harvey");clavisKeywords.push("nothing");clavisKeywords.push("history");clavisKeywords.push("heat energy");clavisKeywords.push("stream");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane trend");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane measurement technique");clavisKeywords.push("jet");clavisKeywords.push("New Orleans");clavisKeywords.push("george w bush");clavisKeywords.push("sowing doubt");clavisKeywords.push("sowing");
clavisKeywords.push("us city");clavisKeywords.push("atlantic hurricane");clavisKeywords.push("Atlantic hurricane");clavisKeywords.push("united states");clavisKeywords.push("chance");clavisKeywords.push("problem");clavisKeywords.push("timothy hall");clavisKeywords.push("Timothy Hall");clavisKeywords.push("atlantic storm");clavisKeywords.push("Atlantic storm");clavisKeywords.push("columbia university");clavisKeywords.push("nasa");clavisKeywords.push("new jersey area");clavisKeywords.push("New Jersey area");
clavisKeywords.push("climate role");clavisKeywords.push("jennifer francis");clavisKeywords.push("Jennifer Francis of Rutgers University");clavisKeywords.push("arctic");clavisKeywords.push("rutgers university");clavisKeywords.push("Jennifer Francis");clavisKeywords.push("sea-ice year");clavisKeywords.push("sea-ice");clavisKeywords.push("climate central");clavisKeywords.push("jet stream idea");clavisKeywords.push("sea level rise");clavisKeywords.push("result");clavisKeywords.push("mit");clavisKeywords.push("kerry emanuel");
clavisKeywords.push("manhattan");clavisKeywords.push("Kerry Emanuel");clavisKeywords.push("flood event");clavisKeywords.push("storm today");clavisKeywords.push("default assumption");clavisKeywords.push("atmospheric research");clavisKeywords.push("national center");clavisKeywords.push("Kevin Trenberth");clavisKeywords.push("Atmospheric Research");clavisKeywords.push("storm thermodynamics");clavisKeywords.push("kevin trenberth");clavisKeywords.push("Kevin Trenberth of the National Center");clavisKeywords.push("Atmospheric");
clavisKeywords.push("Theodore Shepherd");clavisKeywords.push("John Fasullo");clavisKeywords.push("Theodore");clavisKeywords.push("theodore shepherd");clavisKeywords.push("colleague john fasullo");clavisKeywords.push("Fasullo");clavisKeywords.push("steering current");clavisKeywords.push("record rainfall");clavisKeywords.push("researcher today");clavisKeywords.push("case");clavisKeywords.push("climate impact research");clavisKeywords.push("Potsdam");clavisKeywords.push("potsdam institute");clavisKeywords.push("Potsdam Institute");
clavisKeywords.push("Impact");clavisKeywords.push("Stefan Rahmstorf");clavisKeywords.push("Stefan");clavisKeywords.push("Impact Research");clavisKeywords.push("stefan rahmstorf");clavisKeywords.push("rahmstorf");clavisKeywords.push("massachusetts");clavisKeywords.push("degree c");clavisKeywords.push("rainfall event");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane debate");clavisKeywords.push("attribution science");clavisKeywords.push("Penn State University");clavisKeywords.push("David Titley");clavisKeywords.push("national academy");
clavisKeywords.push("david titley");clavisKeywords.push("National Academy");clavisKeywords.push("penn state university");clavisKeywords.push("warming climate");clavisKeywords.push("computing power");clavisKeywords.push("ocean phenomenon");clavisKeywords.push("columbia");clavisKeywords.push("harvey event");clavisKeywords.push("storm intensity");clavisKeywords.push("flow factor");clavisKeywords.push("Harvey event");clavisKeywords.push("stanford");clavisKeywords.push("worst case scenario");clavisKeywords.push("climate analysis");
clavisKeywords.push("titley");clavisKeywords.push("case scenario");clavisKeywords.push("penn state");clavisKeywords.push("michael mann");clavisKeywords.push("Michael Mann");clavisKeywords.push("hurricane event");clavisKeywords.push("climate hurricane debate");clavisKeywords.push("fact");clavisKeywords.push("surge");clavisKeywords.push("ocean temperature");clavisKeywords.push("United States");clavisKeywords.push("Timothy");clavisKeywords.push("jet stream");clavisKeywords.push("Bowman");clavisKeywords.push("computer model");
clavisKeywords.push("Jennifer");clavisKeywords.push("New Jersey");clavisKeywords.push("computing");clavisKeywords.push("connection");clavisKeywords.push("point");clavisKeywords.push("Shepherd");clavisKeywords.push("statement");clavisKeywords.push("air mass");clavisKeywords.push("National Academy of Sciences");clavisKeywords.push("Rutgers");clavisKeywords.push("place");clavisKeywords.push("steering");clavisKeywords.push("Academy");clavisKeywords.push("Emanuel");clavisKeywords.push("EPA");clavisKeywords.push("Rutgers University");
clavisKeywords.push("measurement");clavisKeywords.push("Kevin");clavisKeywords.push("Hall");clavisKeywords.push("heat wave");clavisKeywords.push("current");clavisKeywords.push("George");clavisKeywords.push("Columbia University");clavisKeywords.push("time");clavisKeywords.push("National Center");clavisKeywords.push("Facebook post");clavisKeywords.push("Penn State");clavisKeywords.push("US city");clavisKeywords.push("default");clavisKeywords.push("Kerry");clavisKeywords.push("intensity");clavisKeywords.push("part");
clavisKeywords.push("John");clavisKeywords.push("Institute");clavisKeywords.push("record");clavisKeywords.push("Bush");clavisKeywords.push("technique");clavisKeywords.push("assumption");clavisKeywords.push("George W Bush");clavisKeywords.push("David");clavisKeywords.push("flood");clavisKeywords.push("temperature");clavisKeywords.push("way");clavisKeywords.push("computer");clavisKeywords.push("phenomenon");clavisKeywords.push("spokeswoman");clavisKeywords.push("scenario");clavisKeywords.push("Center");
clavisKeywords.push("wave");clavisKeywords.push("energy");clavisKeywords.push("trend");clavisKeywords.push("air");clavisKeywords.push("doubt");clavisKeywords.push("degree");clavisKeywords.push("colleague");clavisKeywords.push("Facebook");clavisKeywords.push("factor");clavisKeywords.push("power");clavisKeywords.push("idea");clavisKeywords.push("area");clavisTopics.push("Weather");clavisTopicsDFP.push("df");clavisTopics.push("Environment and Nature");clavisTopicsDFP.push("rv");wp_meta_data.clavis.auxiliaries=
clavisAuxs;wp_meta_data.clavis.auxiliary_names=clavisAuxNames;wp_meta_data.clavis.ct=clavisTopicsDFP;wp_meta_data.clavis.topics=clavisTopics;wp_meta_data.clavis.keywords=clavisKeywords.slice(0,25)})()}}catch(e){};</script> </div> <div id="fbvCsU1NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div id="f5A65S1NelfqIq" class="pb-async pb-feature"></div> <div class="pb-container"> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate-false pb-f-async-false pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-bi-abtest" moat-id="bi/abtest|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="bi/abtest" data-pb-fingerprint="0fGmHEvNlqu" id="f0k559zNelfqIq"> <script id="_$wapodarwintoolkitcode">!function(){(function(e,t){function a(e){return function(t,a,n){if(a)e[t]={when:function(){try{return a.call(e[t])}catch(e){return console&&console.warn('[when()@VisitorSegment("'+t+'")]',"Continuing despite error.",e),null}},setup:function(){try{return n.call(e[t])}catch(e){return console&&console.warn('[setup()@VisitorSegment("'+t+'")]',"Continuing despite error.",e),null}}},n&&(e[t]._setupResult=!!e[t].call(e[t]));else if(e[t])return e[t].when.call(e[t],e[t]._setupResult)}}function n(){var e=navigator.userAgent;
return!!(e.match(/Android/i)||e.match(/webOS/i)||e.match(/iPhone/i)||e.match(/iPad/i)||e.match(/iPod/i)||e.match(/BlackBerry/i)||e.match(/Kindle/i)||e.match(/Windows Phone/i)||e.match(/IEMobile/i))}function i(e){var t=localStorage.getItem("_vsData")||"{}";return JSON.parse(t)[e]}function r(e,t){var a=localStorage.getItem("_vsData")||"{}",a=JSON.parse(a);a[e]=t,t=JSON.stringify(a),localStorage.removeItem("_vsData"),localStorage.setItem("_vsData",t)}var o=e._vsdata=e._vsdata||{},s=function(e,t,n){return a(o).call(this,
e,t,n)};s.clone=function(e){var t;if(e)if(null===o||"object"!=typeof o)t=o;else{e=o.constructor();for(t in o)o.hasOwnProperty(t)&&(e[t]=o[t]);t=e}else t=o;return a(t)};var c={};s.resolve=function(e,t){c[e]||(c[e]=[]),setTimeout(function(){c[e].resolved=!0,c[e].argsobj=t;var a,n,i=c[e];for(n=0;i.length,a=i[n];n++)a.fn(t)},0)},s.done=function(e,t){e&&t&&(c[e]||(c[e]=[]),c[e].resolved?t(c[e].argsobj):"function"==typeof t&&c[e].push({fn:t}))},s.Deferred=function(e){this.done=function(t){s.done(e,t)},
this.resolve=function(t){s.resolve(e,t)}},s("desktop",function(){return!n()}),s("!mobile",function(){return!s("mobile")}),s("mobile",function(){return n()}),s("touch",function(){return!!("ontouchstart"in e)}),s("!touch",function(){return!s("touch")}),s("first_visit",function(){var e=i("first_time_start"),t=i("first_time_end");return e&&!t&&18E5<=(new Date).getTime()-(new Date(e)).getTime()?(r("first_time_end",!0),!1):e?!t:(r("first_time_start",(new Date).getTime()),!0)}),e.VisitorSegment=s})(window),
function(e,t,a){function i(e,t){function n(e){this.$dw=i,this.length=0,this._add=function(e,t){var a=t.length;return p.each(e,function(e,n){t[a+e]=n,t.length++}),t},this._add(e,this),this.toArray=function(){var e=[];for(var t in this)this[t]instanceof i.Variant&&e.push(this[t]);return e}}this._id=a,this._config={},this._testData={},this._ignoreBlacklist=a,this._state="uninitialized",this._handlers=[],this._dispatches={},this._id=e||this._id,this._visitor=t||new this.Visitor({},n),f[this._id]=this,
this._handlers=v[this._id]||this._handlers,n.prototype=this.$plugins;var i=this;this._makeResult=function(e){var t=e||[];return t.constructor!==Array&&(t=[t]),new n(t)}}function r(e,t,a,i){var r=[];return p.each(t,function(e,t){var a=t.customOptions,i="";if(a)for(n in a)a.hasOwnProperty(n)&&(i+=[n,a[n]].join("\x3d"));r.push(t.name+i)}),[e,r.sort().join(""),!!a,i].join("")}function o(e,t,a){var n;return p.each(e,function(e,i){if(i[t]==a)return n=i,!1}),n}function s(e){if(!e)throw new Error("invalid name");
return e.toLowerCase()}function c(e){return{name:"Dw__"+e,visit:"Dw__"+e+"__visit",blacklisted:"Dw__"+e+"__blstd",compute:"Dw__"+e+"__cmpted",hash:"Dw__"+e+"__hash",phash:"Dw__"+e+"__phash"}}function l(){return Math.random(0,1)}function m(e,t,a){return e>=t&&e<=a}function d(e,t){var a,n={};for(a in e[t])"boolean"==typeof e[t][a]&&(n[a]=!!e[t][a]);return n}function u(t){var a,n,i,r=t||{},o=0,s=[];for(n in r)i=e(n),i=i&&i.constructor==Boolean,i&&s.push(n),r.hasOwnProperty(n)&&(a=a||!!r[n]&&!!i,r[n]&&
o++);return{match:s,value:!(0!==o?!a:1==Object.keys(r).length)}}var p={each:function(e,t){for(var a,n=0;n<e.length&&("boolean"!=typeof(a=t(n,e[n]))||a);n++);},remove:function(e,t){return t>-1&&e.splice(t,1),e},addClass:function(e,t){e.classList.add(t)},removeClass:function(e,t){e.classList.remove(t)}},v={};if(t._dw&&t._dw.constructor===Array){for(var h=0;h<t._dw.length;h++)v[t._dw[h][0]]||(v[t._dw[h][0]]=[]),v[t._dw[h][0]].push(t._dw[h].slice(1,t._dw[h].length));t._dw.$plugins&&(i.prototype.$plugins=
t._dw.$plugins)}var f={};t._dw=i,i.prototype.collections=function(e){if(!e)return this._collections;this._collections=e},i.prototype.init=function(){function e(){t.applyData.call(t,t.collections.call(t)),"initialized"!=t._state&&t.dispatch.call(t,"ready"),t._state="initialized",t.dispatch.call(t,"init")}this.disabled=!this.collections(),this.dispatch("before");var t=this;this.deferSegments()?this.push(["segments-done",e]):e()},i.prototype.config=function(e){this._config.trackValueDelimiter=e.trackValueDelimiter,
this._config.deferSegments=e.deferSegments,this.collections(e.collections||[])},i.prototype.version=function(){return"2.0.0"},i.prototype.id=function(){return this._id},i.prototype.push=function(e){this._dispatches[e[0]]&&e[1]&&e[1](this,this._dispatches[e[0]]?this._dispatches[e[0]].data:a),this._handlers.push(e)},i.prototype.dispatch=function(e,t){var a=this;this._dispatches[e]={ts:(new Date).getTime(),data:t},this._handlers.length&&p.each(this._handlers,function(t,n){n[0]==e&&n[1]&&n[1](a,a._dispatches[e].data)})},
i.prototype.state=function(){return this._state},i.prototype.trackValueDelimiter=function(){return this._config.trackValueDelimiter},i.prototype.deferSegments=function(){return this._config.deferSegments},i.prototype.applyData=function(e){var t;this.disabled||!this._detectLocalStorage()||this._isOptOut()||(t=this._datastore={tests:[]},this._ignoreBlacklist=this._getLocalItem("Dw__ib"),p.each(e||[],function(e,a){"boolean"!=typeof a.disabled||a.disabled||Array.prototype.push.apply(t.tests,a.tests)}),
this.collection(t))},i.prototype.collection=function(e){function t(e){if(!e.name)throw new Error("missing name");var t=new this.Test(e,this);switch(0==Object.keys(t).length&&t.constructor==Object||(this._testData[e.name]=t),t.state){case "registered":this.dispatch("variant-register",e.name);break;case "deregistered":this.dispatch("variant-deregister",e.name);break;case "persisted":this.dispatch("variant-persist",e.name)}return this.dispatch("variant-done",e.name),t}var a,n=this,i=[],r=[];e.disabled||
(a=e.tests||[],p.each(a,function(e,t){t["x-linked"]?i.push(t):r.push(t)}),p.each(i,function(e,a){if(a=t.call(n,a),a.variation&&a.variation.run)return!1}),p.each(r,function(e,a){t.call(n,a)}))},i.prototype.ignoreBlacklist=function(e){e?(this._ignoreBlacklist="yes",this._setLocalItem("Dw__ib","yes")):(this._ignoreBlacklist=a,this._removeLocalItem("Dw__ib"))},i.prototype.optOut=function(){this._setLocalItem("Dw__OO","yes")},i.prototype.getVariant=function(e,t,n){function i(e){var a=!r.disabled&&r._testData[e]||
{},n=a.variation||new r.Variant(a,r);return t||!a.variation||n.historic||(n.historic=!0),n}var r=this;if("."==e[0])return this.$commands[e].call(this);e=e.constructor!==Array?[e]:e;var o=[];return p.each(e,function(e,t){var n=r.getTest(t),s=r._testData[t],c=s&&s.variation?s.variation.historic:a;r._testData[t]=new r.Test(n._originalData,r),r._testData[t].variation&&(r._testData[t].variation.historic=c),o.push(i(t))}),n?o:this._makeResult(o)},i.prototype.use=function(e){this.getVariant(e,!1,!1)},i.prototype.get=
function(e){return this.getVariant(e,!1,!1)},i.prototype.getTestOf=function(e){return e.getTest()},i.prototype.getToolkitOf=function(e){return e.getToolkit()},i.prototype.set=function(e,t){var a=f[this.id()];a&&0==this.find({name:e,run:!0}).length&&(a._mset=a._mset||{},a._mset[e]={},a._mset[e][t]=!0)},i.prototype.$commands={".get_history":function(){return this.find({historic:!0})}},i.prototype.segment=e,i.prototype.find=function(e){var t=this,a=e||{},n=[];return p.each(this.collections(),function(e,
i){p.each(i.tests,function(e,i){var r=0,o=t.getVariant(i.name,!0,!0)[0];for(var s in a)a[s]instanceof RegExp?(a[s].test(i[s])||"string"==typeof o.name&&a[s].test(o[s]))&&r++:(i[s]===a[s]||"string"==typeof o.name&&o[s]===a[s])&&r++;r==Object.keys(a).length&&n.push(o)})}),this._makeResult(n)},i.prototype.clear=function(){delete f[this.id()]._mset;var e=this;p.each(this.collections(),function(t,a){p.each(a.tests,function(t,a){e._deregisterVariant(a.name)})})},i.prototype.$handlers={applyClass:function(e,
t,a){p.removeClass(this,"dw-not-loaded"),p.addClass(this,"dw-"+t+"-"+a+"-"+e)}},i.prototype.applyClass=function(e,t,a){var n=function(e){var t=e.split(".");return{test:t[0],variant:t[1]}}(t),i=this.getVariant(n.test),r=i.is(n.variant);n.test&&n.variant&&(this.$handlers.applyClass.call(e,r,n.test,n.variant),a&&a.call(e,r,n.test,n.variant))},i.prototype.$plugins=i.prototype.$plugins||{},i.prototype.$plugins.add=function(e){return e="string"==typeof e?this.$dw.getVariant(e):e,this.$dw._makeResult(this._add(e,
this)),this},i.prototype.$plugins.is=function(e){function t(e,t){return!!e&&e===t.name}var a=!!this.length;return p.each(this,function(n,i){t(e,i)||(a=!1)}),a},i.prototype.$plugins.clear=function(e){var t=this.$dw;p.each(this,function(e,a){t._deregisterVariant(a.$tc.name)})},i.prototype.$plugins.has=function(e){function t(e,t){return!!e&&e===t.name}var a=!1;return p.each(this,function(n,i){t(e,i)&&(a=!0)}),a},i.prototype.$plugins.toTrackVar=function(e,t,a){function n(e,a){if(a.trackvars){var n=[],
i=e||(a.trackvars[0]?a.trackvars[0].name:"");return p.each(a.trackvars,function(e,t){s(i)===s(t.name)&&n.push(t.value)}),(n=n.join(o))&&(t?t+o:"")+n}}var i=this.$dw,r=[],o=a||i.trackValueDelimiter();return p.each(this,function(t,a){var i=n(e,a);i&&r.push(i)}),r.join(o)},i.prototype.$plugins.getTrackVar=i.prototype.$plugins.toTrackVar,i.prototype._deregisterVariant=function(e){var t=c(e);this._removeLocalItem(t.name),this._removeLocalItem(t.visit),this._removeLocalItem(t.blacklisted),this._removeLocalItem(t.compute),
this._removeLocalItem(t.hash),this._removeLocalItem(t.phash)},i.prototype._detectLocalStorage=function(){var e="_adwi_";try{return this._setLocalItem(e,e),this._removeLocalItem(e),!0}catch(e){return!1}},i.prototype._isOptOut=function(){return"yes"==this._getLocalItem("Dw__OO")},i.prototype._removeLocalItem=function(e){var t=[e,this.id()].join("|");localStorage.removeItem(t)},i.prototype._getLocalItem=function(e){var t=[e,this.id()].join("|");try{return localStorage.getItem(t)}catch(e){return null}},
i.prototype._setLocalItem=function(e,t){var n=[e,this.id()].join("|");this._getLocalItem(n)&&this._removeLocalItem(n);try{return localStorage.setItem(n,t)}catch(e){return a}},i.prototype.getTest=function(e){return this._testData[e]||new this.Test({},this)},i.prototype.visitor=function(){return this._visitor},i.prototype.Visitor=function(e,t){this.has=function(e){function a(e){var t=e instanceof i.prototype.Variant?e.getTest():e||{};return"registered"==t.state||"persisted"==t.state}var n;return t&&
e instanceof t?p.each(e.toArray(),function(e,t){if(!(n=a(t)))return!1}):n=a(e),n}},i.prototype.Variant=function(e,t){var a=e||{};this.nocollect=!a.collect,this.historic=a.historic||!1,this.run=a.run||!1;var n=a.variation||{};this.getTest=function(){return t.getTest(a.name)},this.name=n.name||"",this.trackvars=n.track||[],this.customOptions=n.customOptions||{}},i.prototype.Test=function(e,t){var n=e.name||"",i=c(n),r=e.increment||0,o=e.variations||[],s=e["x-persist"]||!1,l=e.blacklist&&e.blacklist.referrers||
[],m="yes"==t._getLocalItem(i.blacklisted),p={domains:l,segment:d(e,"segment")};this._originalData=e,this.data=function(e,t){if(t==a)return this._originalData[e];this._originalData[e]=t},this.getToolkit=function(){return t};var v=u(p.segment);this.segments=p.segment?v.match:[];var h=!!p.segment&&v.value;m||t._getLocalItem(i.blacklisted)||(m=t._isBlacklisted(p.domains)||!h,t._setLocalItem(i.blacklisted,m?"yes":"no"));var f=!!o.length,_=o.length&&new t.Variant(t._registerVariant(n,o,m,r,h,s),t);this.name=
n,f&&e.active&&!_.nocollect&&(this.variation=_);var y=f&&e.active?e.defaultTrack:[];m&&Array.prototype.push.apply(y,e.blacklist?e.blacklist.track:[]),(y.length&&_.nocollect||!f||!_||!h)&&(this.variation=new t.Variant({name:n,variation:{track:h?y:[]}},t)),f&&_&&h?_&&_.run?this.state="registered":this.state="persisted":(t._deregisterVariant(n),this.state="deregistered")},i.prototype._registerVariant=function(e,t,a,n,i,s){var d=c(e),u={cur:s?r(e,[],!1,n):r(e,t,a,n),old:s?this._getLocalItem(d.phash):
this._getLocalItem(d.hash)},v=this._getLocalItem(d.name),h="yes"==this._getLocalItem(d.visit),_="yes"==this._getLocalItem(d.compute),y=function(e,t){var e=parseFloat(e.customOptions.target),t=parseFloat(t.customOptions.target);return e<t?-1:e>t?1:0},g=f[this.id()],k=o(t,"name",v),b=!(!i||(_||a||"string"==typeof v||k)&&(!_||u.cur==u.old));if(b)if(g._mset&&g._mset[e])p.each(t,function(t,a){g._mset[e][a.name]&&(k=a)});else{t.sort(y);var w=[],L=0,x=0;p.each(t,function(e,t){var a=t.customOptions&&t.customOptions.target;
if(a){a=parseFloat(a)/100,L+=a;var n={value:[x,L]};x+=a,w.push(n)}});var O=l();p.each(w,function(e,t){m(O,t.value[0],t.value[1])&&(v=e)}),k=t[v]}k?this._setLocalItem(d.name,k.name):this._setLocalItem(d.name,"_default"),this._setLocalItem(d.visit,"yes"),this._setLocalItem(d.compute,"yes"),this._setLocalItem(d.hash,u.cur),this._setLocalItem(d.phash,u.cur);var C=k&&(!a||h)&&{name:e,variation:k,collect:!0};return C||(C={name:e}),C.run=b,C},i.prototype._isBlacklisted=function(e){function t(e){return e.replace(/\./g,
"\\.").replace(/\-/g,"\\-")}function a(e){var a=new RegExp("^(http://)?(www\\.)?"+t(e),"gi");return!e&&!document.referrer||(e&&document.referrer.match(a)||[]).length>0}var n,i=e||[];return this._ignoreBlacklist||p.each(i,function(e,t){return!(n=a(t))}),n},e("darwin-toolkit:v2.0.0",function(){return!0}),t._dw.push=function(e){f[e[0]]?(f[e[0]]._dispatches[e[1]]&&e[2]&&e[2](f[e[0]]),f[e[0]]._handlers.push(e.slice(1,e.length))):(v[e[0]]||(v[e[0]]=[]),v[e[0]].push(e.slice(1,e.length)))},t._dw}(VisitorSegment,
this),function(e){var t=new e("global"),a={};a.trackValueDelimiter=",",a.deferSegments=!0,a.collections=[{name:"recommendation",disabled:!1,tests:[{name:"recommendation-influencersexperiments",active:!0,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:2,segment:{},_token:"107657",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"10"},name:"influencers",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments:influencers"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments:influencers"},
{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments-107657"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments-107657"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments-107657"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"recommendation-influencersexperiments-107657"}]}]},{name:"article",
disabled:!1,tests:[{name:"article-mostReadOpinion",active:!0,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{},_token:"e1236d",variations:[],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadOpinion:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadOpinion:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadOpinion-e1236d"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadOpinion-e1236d"}]},{name:"article-oneClickNL",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1",
"x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{"not logged in mobile":!0},_token:"60e020",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"visual",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:visual"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:visual"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"}]},{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"oneClick",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:oneClick"},{name:"prop56",
dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:oneClick"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"}]},{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"oneClickAlt",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:oneClickAlt"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:oneClickAlt"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",
dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-oneClickNL-60e020"}]},{name:"article-breakingnews",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{desktop:!0},_token:"3d7545",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"34"},name:"nobreakingnews",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:nobreakingnews"},
{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:nobreakingnews"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"}]},{customOptions:{target:"33"},name:"sectionbreakingnews",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:sectionbreakingnews"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:sectionbreakingnews"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"}]},
{customOptions:{target:"33"},name:"allbreakingnews",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:allbreakingnews"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:allbreakingnews"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"},
{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-breakingnews-3d7545"}]},{name:"article-mostReadNum",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{},_token:"c331cb",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"ten",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum:ten"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum:ten"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum-c331cb"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum-c331cb"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",
dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum-c331cb"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-mostReadNum-c331cb"}]},{name:"article-curatedContent",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:1,segment:{},_token:"7d2dac",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"enabledhpfirst",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:enabledhpfirst"},
{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:enabledhpfirst"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"}]},{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"enabledprfirst",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:enabledprfirst"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:enabledprfirst"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"}]},
{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"enabledhponly",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:enabledhponly"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:enabledhponly"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,
value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"article-curatedContent-7d2dac"}]}]},{name:"modal",disabled:!1,tests:[{name:"modal-adblock_v1",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:6,segment:{adblock_generic:!0},_token:"61f727",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"95"},name:"enabled",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1:enabled"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1:enabled"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1-61f727"},
{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1-61f727"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1-61f727"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v1-61f727"}]},{name:"modal-adblock_v2",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"1",increment:0,segment:{adblock_generic:!0},_token:"275edf",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"var1",
track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:var1"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:var1"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"}]},{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"var2",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:var2"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:var2"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"}]},
{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"var3",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:var3"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:var3"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"}]},{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"controlvar",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:controlvar"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:controlvar"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"},
{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"modal-adblock_v2-275edf"}]}]},{name:"video",disabled:!1,tests:[{name:"video-adtimeout",active:!1,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:3,segment:{},_token:"397458",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"10"},
name:"8s",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout:8s"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout:8s"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout-397458"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout-397458"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout-397458"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"video-adtimeout-397458"}]}]},{name:"upgrade",
disabled:!1,tests:[{name:"upgrade-teaser",active:!0,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:2,segment:{},_token:"b68e2b",variations:[],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-teaser:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-teaser:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-teaser-b68e2b"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-teaser-b68e2b"}]},{name:"upgrade-toolkit_v110",active:!0,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{},
_token:"fe334d",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"variant_1",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110:variant_1"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110:variant_1"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110-fe334d"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110-fe334d"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,
value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110-fe334d"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-toolkit_v110-fe334d"}]},{name:"upgrade-remindmelater",active:!0,"x-persist":!1,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:1,segment:{},_token:"6270be",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"100"},name:"remindmelater",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater:remindmelater"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater:remindmelater"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater-6270be"},{name:"prop56",
dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater-6270be"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater-6270be"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"upgrade-remindmelater-6270be"}]}]},{name:"nav",disabled:!1,tests:[{name:"nav-homeLink",active:!0,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{desktop:!0},_token:"51c40b",variations:[],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",
dynamic:!1,value:"nav-homeLink:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-homeLink:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-homeLink-51c40b"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-homeLink-51c40b"}]},{name:"nav-notiJewel",active:!0,"x-persist":!0,"x-status":"1","x-linked":"0",increment:0,segment:{},_token:"4e2542",variations:[{customOptions:{target:"25"},name:"jewel",track:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel:jewel"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel:jewel"},{name:"list1",
dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel-4e2542"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel-4e2542"}]}],defaultTrack:[{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel:default"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel:default"},{name:"list1",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel-4e2542"},{name:"prop56",dynamic:!1,value:"nav-notiJewel-4e2542"}]}]}],t.config(a),this.__dwCallback__?this.__dwCallback__(t):t.init()}(this._dw)}();</script> </div> <div class="moat-trackable pb-f-theme-normal pb-f-dehydrate- pb-f-async- pb-feature pb-layout-item pb-f-page-contextual-linking" moat-id="page/contextual-linking|business" data-chain-name="no-name" data-feature-name="no-name" data-feature-id="page/contextual-linking" data-pb-fingerprint="0fSXJuesGqb" id="f0rfOeCNelfqIq"> <script>try{if(wp_meta_data){if(!wp_meta_data.contextualLinking)wp_meta_data.contextualLinking={};(function(){wp_meta_data.contextualLinking.matches=[]})()}}catch(e){};</script> </div> </div></section> <div class="pb-container"> </div></div> <script>ResourceBundle.when("pb-r-identity").then(function(){window.TWP&&TWP.Analytics&&TWP.Analytics.init({trackScrolling:{omniture:false},snowflake:true,suppressTrackPageLoad:!wp_pb.StaticMethods.isPageHydrated()?true:false})});</script> <noscript><img src="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/p?c1=2&c2=3005617&cv=2.0&cj=1"/></noscript> <noscript><img src="//me.effectivemeasure.net/em_image" alt="" style="position:absolute; left:-5px;"/></noscript> <script>document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/load_async/8a2dfd536e.js?_\x3d5b7df");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/headjs/8bb9d8351d.js?_\x3d69d73");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/p/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/head.js?_\x3d9b183");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/hi-pri-js/e7f066f51e.js?_\x3d3b73d");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/p/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/hi-pri-render.js?_\x3d9b183");
pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/js/23cef797d0.js?_\x3dc0d52");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/p/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/render.js?_\x3d9b183");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/p/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/instance.js?_\x3d9b183");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/after_features/7dfb557743.js?_\x3dafb63");pbDeferredScripts.push("https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/utils/setRplamprCookie.js");pbDeferredScripts.push("/pb/gr/ro/default-article/ryDnRS1NelfqIq/after_features/96e0186d35.js?_\x3dafb63");
wp_import(pbDeferredScripts).always(function(){document.dispatchEvent(new CustomEvent("pb-r-defer-js"))})});</script> <script>(function(){if("__twpCookieMonster__"in document)document.__twpCookieMonster__.ommNom()})();</script> <script>ResourceBundle.processInlineScripts();</script> <script>window.pbThirdPartyScripts=window.pbThirdPartyScripts||new Array;</script> <script>window.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){});
window.addEventListener("load",function(){function applyTwitter(){try{var $tweetAuthors=$(".tweet-authors");var $tweetTimelines=$(".twitter-timeline");if((!!$tweetAuthors.length||!!$tweetTimelines.length)&&(!window.twttr||!twttr.widgets))$.ajax({dataType:"script",cache:true,url:"//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js",success:function(data){if(!!$tweetAuthors.length)$tweetAuthors.find(".pb-twitter-follow.unprocessed").removeClass("unprocessed")}})}catch(e){}}if(wp_pb.StaticMethods.isPageHydrated())applyTwitter();
__e.push(["shamble:end",function(){applyTwitter()}]);try{$("body").append('\x3cimg src\x3d"https://amplifypixel.outbrain.com/pixel?mid\x3d00bb70a80ee8f020d9011cbcef307fe64d"\x3e')}catch(e){}wp_import(pbThirdPartyScripts).always(function(){document.dispatchEvent(new CustomEvent("pb-r-third-party-js"))});!function(f,b,e,v,n,t,s){if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=function(){n.callMethod?n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments)};if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;n.push=n;n.loaded=!0;n.version="2.0";n.queue=[];
t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!0;t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)}(window,document,"script","https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js");fbq("init","1063176057035408");fbq("track","PageView")});</script> <script>window.pbExternalResourcesLoaded=window.pbExternalResourcesLoaded||new Array;window.pbFootResourceGroups=window.pbFootResourceGroups||new Array;pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"hi-pri-js","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/default-hi-pri.js?_\x3d3b73d");pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"pageResources","name":"hi-pri-render.js","fileType":"js"});pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"js","fileType":"js"});
pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/iabc/iabc-cookie.js?_\x3dd47ff");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/service-worker-registration.js?_\x3d8fdcf");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/condition-manager.min.js?_\x3db59fb");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/conditions.js?_\x3ddc047");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/moment.min.js?_\x3db8874");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/inline-content.js?_\x3df60bb");
pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"pageResources","name":"render.js","fileType":"js"});pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"pageResources","name":"instance.js","fileType":"js"});pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"after_features","fileType":"js"});pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/default-after-features.js?_\x3da3d2d");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/private-browsing.js?_\x3d84392");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/utils/setRplamprCookie.js");
pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/article-layout-after-features.js?_\x3db126f");pbExternalResourcesLoaded.push("/pb/resources/js/abtests/segments.js?_\x3d9d2a3");pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"content_type_blog","fileType":"js"});pbFootResourceGroups.push({"resourceType":"externalResources","name":"third_party","fileType":"js"});</script> </body> </html><script>
  var _uri = "/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/08/30/katrina-sandy-harvey-the-debate-over-climate-and-hurricanes-is-getting-louder-and-louder/"
  var _context = "/pb"
  var _outputType = "default-article"
  var _rid = "ryDnRS1NelfqIq"
  //polyfill
String.prototype.endsWith||Object.defineProperty(String.prototype,"endsWith",{value:function(t,e){var n=this.toString();(void 0===e||e>n.length)&&(e=n.length),e-=t.length;var r=n.indexOf(t,e);return-1!==r&&r===e}});
/* Async loader code here */
window.pageBuilder = window.pageBuilder || {};

window.pageBuilder.featureLoaded =  window.pageBuilder.featureLoaded || function(){};
window.pageBuilder.chainLoaded = window.pageBuilder.chainLoaded || function(chain,apiResponse){
        var d = window.document;
        for (var i = 0; i < apiResponse.featureIds.length; i++) {
            var f = d.getElementById(apiResponse.featureIds[i]);
            window.pageBuilder.featureLoaded(f);
        }
    };
window.pageBuilder._isNestedFeature = window.pageBuilder._isNestedFeature || function (element) {
        if(!element.parentElement) return false;
        var parent = element.parentElement;
        if (parent.className && parent.className.split(' ').indexOf("pb-feature")>=0) return true;
        return window.pageBuilder._isNestedFeature(parent);
    };
window.pageBuilder._executeAsyncFeatureScripts = window.pageBuilder._executeAsyncFeatureScripts || function(s){eval(s)};

window.pageBuilder._getJson = window.pageBuilder._getJson || function(url, success, failure) {
    var xmlhttp;
    failure = failure|| function () {};
    if (window.XMLHttpRequest) {
        xmlhttp = new XMLHttpRequest();
    } else {
        xmlhttp = new ActiveXObject("Microsoft.XMLHTTP");
    }
    xmlhttp.onreadystatechange = function() {
        if (xmlhttp.readyState == 4) {
            if(xmlhttp.status == 200){
                try {
                    success.call(null, JSON.parse(xmlhttp.responseText));
                } catch (e) {
                    failure.call(null, xmlhttp, e)
                }
            } else  {
                failure.call(null, xmlhttp);
            }
        }
    };
    xmlhttp.open("GET", url, true);
    xmlhttp.send();
};

window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncFeature = window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncFeature || function (id) {
        var d = window.document;
        function injectFeatureDom(id, featureRendering) {
            var element = d.getElementById(id);
            var resources = featureRendering.pageResources || {};
            element.outerHTML = featureRendering.rendering;
            element = d.getElementById(id); //update the element
            var scripts = Array.prototype.slice.call(element.getElementsByTagName("script"));
            for (var i = 0; i < scripts.length; i++) {
                if (scripts[i].src != "") {
                    var s = d.createElement("script");
                    s.setAttribute("src", scripts[i].src);
                    d.body.appendChild(s);
                }
                else {
                    window.pageBuilder._executeAsyncFeatureScripts(scripts[i].innerHTML); //eval isn't evil always.
                }
            }
            for(var file in resources) {
                if(resources.hasOwnProperty(file) && file.endsWith(".js")) {
                    var s1 = d.createElement("script");
                    s1.setAttribute("src", resources[file]);
                    d.body.appendChild(s1);
                }
            }
            window.pageBuilder.featureLoaded(element);
        }
        var url = _context + "/api/v2/render/feature/"+id+"?rid="+_rid+"&contentUri="+_uri;
        window.pageBuilder._getJson(url, function(obj) { injectFeatureDom(id, obj); });
    };

window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncChain = window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncChain || function (id) {
        var d = window.document;
        function injectChainDom(id, apiResponse) {
            var element = d.getElementById(id);
            var resources = apiResponse.pageResources || {};
            element.outerHTML = apiResponse.rendering;
            element = d.getElementById(id); //update the element
            var scripts = Array.prototype.slice.call(element.getElementsByTagName("script"));
            for (var i = 0; i < scripts.length; i++) {
                if (scripts[i].src != "") {
                    var s = d.createElement("script");
                    s.setAttribute("src", scripts[i].src);
                    d.body.appendChild(s);
                }
                else {
                    window.pageBuilder._executeAsyncFeatureScripts(scripts[i].innerHTML); //eval isn't evil always.
                }
            }
            for(var file in resources) {
                if(resources.hasOwnProperty(file) && file.endsWith(".js")) {
                    var s1 = d.createElement("script");
                    s1.setAttribute("src", resources[file]);
                    d.body.appendChild(s1);
                }
            }
            window.pageBuilder.chainLoaded(element,apiResponse);
        }
        var url = _context + "/api/v2/render/chain/"+id+"?rid="+_rid+"&contentUri="+_uri;
        window.pageBuilder._getJson(url, function(obj) { injectChainDom(id, obj); });
    };

window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncFeatures = window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncFeatures || function () {
        var d = window.document;
        var scriptsToAdd = [];
        var featuresLoaded = [];
        function injectAsyncFeatures(apiResp){
            for(var fid in apiResp){
                if (!apiResp.hasOwnProperty(fid)) continue;

                var element = d.getElementById(fid);
                var resources = apiResp[fid].pageResources || {};
                element.outerHTML = apiResp[fid].rendering;
                element = d.getElementById(fid); //update the element
                var scripts = Array.prototype.slice.call(element.getElementsByTagName("script"));
                for (var i = 0; i < scripts.length; i++) {
                    if (scripts[i].src != "") {
                        var s = d.createElement("script");
                        s.setAttribute("src", scripts[i].src);
                        d.body.appendChild(s);
                    }
                    else {
                        window.pageBuilder._executeAsyncFeatureScripts(scripts[i].innerHTML); //eval isn't evil always.
                    }
                }
                for(var file in resources) {
                    if(resources.hasOwnProperty(file) && file.endsWith(".js")) {
                        resources[file].forEach(function(src){
                            if (scriptsToAdd.indexOf(src) === -1) { scriptsToAdd.push(src) }
                        });
                    }
                }
                featuresLoaded.push(element);
            }
            scriptsToAdd.forEach(function (src) {
                var s = d.createElement("script");
                s.setAttribute("src", src);
                d.body.appendChild(s);
            });
            featuresLoaded.forEach(function(element){
                window.pageBuilder.featureLoaded(element);
            });
        }
    var url = _context + "/api/v2/async/features?rid="+_rid+"&contentUri="+_uri;
    window.pageBuilder._getJson(url, function(resp) { injectAsyncFeatures(resp)});
};
window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncChains = window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncChains || function () {
        var d = window.document;
        var chains = d.getElementsByClassName("pb-async pb-chain");
        var ids = [].slice.call(chains).map(function (node) { return node.id; });
        ids.forEach(function(id) {
            window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncChain(id);
        });
    };

window.pageBuilder.loadAsync = window.pageBuilder.loadAsync || function(){
        window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncFeatures();
        window.pageBuilder.loadAsyncChains();
};

window.pageBuilder.loadAsync();

</script>